When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Already a subscriber? Log in .

You've reached your limit of one free article.

Get unlimited access to Worldcrunch

You can cancel anytime .


Exclusive International news coverage

Ad-free experience NEW

Weekly digital Magazine NEW

9 daily & weekly Newsletters

Access to Worldcrunch archives

Free trial

30-days free access, then $2.90
per month.

Annual Access BEST VALUE

$19.90 per year, save $14.90 compared to monthly billing. save $14.90.

Subscribe to Worldcrunch

One Clear Sign Iran's Protests Are Working: An End To Western Appeasement

The Western world has taken note of the desperate fury of Iranians protesting against a 40-year dictatorship in their country. Now there are signs that the West has finally lost patience with the a regime based on repression and subterfuge.

One Clear Sign Iran's Protests Are Working: An End To Western Appeasement

At a protest in Istanbul outside the Iranian Consulate

Ahmed Rafat

-Analysis -

More than a month of anti-government protests and strikes may have finally dragged Western governments from their inaction and complacency toward the Iranian regime. They may even have concluded, belatedly, that it would be best to postpone the multilateral talks to renew a nuclear pact with Tehran .

The slogans, demands and grievances of Iranians against state violence have finally broken through abroad, as the European Union , the United Kingdom, Canada and the United States gingerly add names to their lists of sanctioned Iran officials and agencies.

Admittedly, the latest inclusions approved by the EU were not related to the suppression of protests in Iran but to the military supplies sent to Russia.

What has prompted the West to temper its appeasement of the Islamic Republic?

It must be nothing more and nothing less than the courage and resilience of Iranian protesters, displayed not just for a few days but for well over a month, since beginning in mid-September.

How Iran swayed the West

The movement has stood firm in spite of regime agents killing more than 250 protesters including 27 children and teenagers , and arresting thousands more — with all the terrible possibilities detention entails in Iran.

Biden's own discourse has changed

This revolt has brought the name of its first victim, Mahsa Amini and its slogan — Woman, Life and Freedom — to global recognition. It has brought out crowds in support of Iranians and especially Iranian women . All this is unprecedented since 1979, when the Islamic Republic came into being.

Western governments have to respect public opinion in their countries, thanks to the intermittent institution of general elections. People can always vote against governments that ignore their expectations, and the protests of Iranians have certainly captured hearts and minds in many countries. This has in turn prompted an unprecedented mass of gestures, acts and events to support Iranians and denounce the Islamic Republic .

Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi at the 6th CICA Summit in Astana, Kazakhstan

Iranian Presidency/ZUMA

Is the U.S. changing position on Iran?

On Oct. 20, 14 countries with female foreign ministers held an online meeting at the invitation of the Canadian Foreign Minister, Mélanie Joly, to discuss support for Iranian women. This was a first. The Democratic administration of U.S. President Joseph Biden has also changed its line and for the first time. It invited more than the usual lobbies — which often promote rapprochement with the Islamic Republic — for conversations on Iran.

Some of the new interlocutors included Nazanin Boniadi , a prominent actress, and the author Roya Hakakian , who met with the U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken and his advisers to convey the views of ordinary Iranians. Boniadi also met with Vice President Kamala Harris and the National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan.

Biden's own discourse has changed, as shown by some public expressions of support for the protesters. His Democratic predecessor, Barack Obama, has voiced regret over his administration's failure to support mass Iran protests in 2009 . The reactions might have something to do with Congressional elections on Nov. 2, in which the Democrats are not expected to do well. But while the aim may be to keep votes, it's a case of a glass half full and welcome as far as it goes.

A regime under pressure

We shouldn't overlook the proactive role of Iranian exiles, whatever their political tendencies, and the influence they have managed to wield. Many bi-national personalities — from actors and actresses, to journalists, artists, influencers, parliamentarians and businessmen — have loudly voiced their support for protesting Iranians and contributed to changing the policies of their countries of residence. Many have simply taken to the streets to voice their indignation.

The Islamic Republic is facing multiple pressures today : lingering protests, strikes and a return of sanctions. It is cornered and bruised — though not yet down and out — and resorting to its usual tactics of threats, kidnappings and regional meddling. In a month of protests it has detained 33 individuals identified as foreign nationals involved in sedition.

According to an Italian diplomat, Iran's foreign minister, Hussein Amirabdullahian, has told his Italian counterpart that if the Europeans persist with measures against the regime, they should expect these detainees, including an Italian, to spend a long time in jail. He knows that unlike his own government, European countries are concerned with the lives of their nationals.

EU foreign ministers displayed their usual caution when recently approving more sanctions on Iran without a formal and public rebuke of its actions . The EU needs unanimity to act effectively and Iranian officials, like their mentors in Russia , have cottoned onto that. Still, there is real hope that the limit to the world's patience — and to the Islamic Republic's dishonorable and crafty staying power — is coming to an end.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

FOCUS: Israel-Palestine War

Turkey-Israel Relations? It's Complicated — But The Gaza War Is Different

Turkish President Erdogan has now called on the International Criminal Court to go after Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu for war crimes, as the clash between the two regional powers has reached a new low.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Elias Kassem

Since the arrival two decades ago of now President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Turkey’s relationship with Israel has been a mix of deep ideological conflict and cover-your-eyes realpolitik .

On the one hand, Erdogan has positioned himself as a kind of global spokesman for the Palestinian cause . His Justice and Development Party has long publicly and financially supported Hamas, which shares similar roots in the 20th-century Muslim Brotherhood movement.

And yet, since 2001 when Erdogan first came to power, trade between Turkey and Israel has multiplied from $1.41 to $8.9 billion in 2022. Moreover, both countries see major potential in transporting newly discovered Israeli natural gas to Europe, via Turkey.

The logic of shared interests clashes with the passions and posturing of high-stakes geopolitics. Diplomatic relations have been cut off, then restored, and since October 7, the countries’ respective ambassadors have been recalled, with accusations flying between Erdogan and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Still, over the past 48 hours, Turkish-Israeli relations may have hit an all-time low.

Keep reading... Show less

The latest