When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

You've reach your limit of free articles.

Get unlimited access to Worldcrunch

You can cancel anytime.

SUBSCRIBERS BENEFITS

Ad-free experience NEW

Exclusive international news coverage

Access to Worldcrunch archives

Monthly Access

30-day free trial, then $2.90 per month.

Annual Access BEST VALUE

$19.90 per year, save $14.90 compared to monthly billing.save $14.90.

Subscribe to Worldcrunch
India

The Indian Snake Charmers Refusing To Change Their Tune

Snake charming is no longer legal
Snake charming is no longer legal
Bismillah Geelani

NEW DELHI — Wearing orange dresses with matching turbans, a group of folk musicians play tunes on their pungi, also known as been, a traditional flute made from gourd fruit.

The audience at Surajkund Craft Fair on the outskirts of the Indian capital is enthralled. Many break into dance. But the musicians themselves don't look very enthusiastic. "This is not what we want to do; it's been thrust upon us," says Badri Nath, 75, who heads the troupe. "But since our original work has been banned, this is all we can do. Whether we are happy or not doesn't matter."

Badri and his companions are snake charmers. For generations, they made their living performing with snakes on streets and in villages across India.

But snake charming is no longer legal, and Badri says they're no longer able to make ends meet.

We have not only lost our livelihood, we have been cut off from our roots.

"Snakes and snake charmers have been together from time immemorial. It's the only thing we and our ancestors have known, and we lived on it for centuries," Badri explained. "Now it has been taken away from us. We have not only lost our livelihood, we have been cut off from our roots. These performances here can sustain a few us for a few days. But what happens after that? And what about the rest of the community?"

Snake charming was banned under the Wildlife Protection Act amendment in 1991. The law prohibits catching, owning and performing with snakes.

Initially, the government did not enforce the ban, and snake charmers continued. But as animal rights activists pressured the authorities to clamp down on snake charmers, their numbers declined. Kartik Satyanarayan, from the conservation group Wildlife SOS, says the tradition is abusive.

"They basically dehydrate them; they stick them in a box and forget about them, use them whenever they want to perform or beg for some money from people, and once the job is done they just throw the snake away because they don't care," says Satyanarayan.

"And the snake then sometimes dies; it takes some weeks of starvation to die because the fangs have been removed, the venom glands have been removed, they can't really hunt and fend for themselves anymore," he said.

Some snake charmers refuse to give up the tradition — Photo: Jon Hurd

But snake charmers strongly deny charges of animal cruelty.

The ban affected an estimated 800,000 snake charmers in India. Many moved into other occupations like rickshaw pulling, street vending, construction, or agricultural labor. But according to the snake charmers' union, the overwhelming majority remains jobless.

Some refuse to give up the tradition. Snake charmers in yellow dhoti kurta and turbans performed recently on a Delhi street. They arranged a couple of wicker baskets in front of them and started playing the been. As soon as people gathered, one of them opened his baskets and three snakes rose waving their heads, looking like they were dancing to the music of his been. He then moved closer to the audience, showing them the reptiles and explaining the differences between the species. But when a policeman arrived, the snake charmer quickly escaped.

The charmer's brother, Birju Nath, says they're used to playing this game of hide and seek with police and forest officials.

"They arrest us and take away our snakes. But if we stop doing this, what else is there for us? We have no business or land to fall back on. Without this we will simply starve to death," Birju said.

The younger generation shows no interest in continuing the legacy, a development welcomed by Satyanarayan from Wildlife SOS. "Life moves on," he says. "Our lives have changed culturally. Why should the poor snake charmer continue to live a life of poverty, and disadvantage himself and his family, just because some other people like to see that and like to call it tradition?"

Back at the craft fair, the snake charmers are playing a Sufi song — or Qawwali, as the audience sways to the music.

With the snakes being sent back to their natural habitat, the snake charmers are pinning their hopes on their instruments.

"There are so many musical instruments out there but the been stands out," says Vikrambir Nath, a member of the troupe.

"It belongs exclusively to us and it is completely homemade. We make it from gourd and bamboo. It represents us as a community and our unique way of life, and it is part of India's cultural heritage. It needs to be protected and that would require state patronage and promotion." He says that unless the government invests in preserving the history and music of the snake charmers, within a few decades the centuries-old practice will disappear without a trace.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Green

Forest Networks? Revisiting The Science Of Trees And Funghi "Reaching Out"

A compelling story about how forest fungal networks communicate has garnered much public interest. Is any of it true?

Thomas Brail films the roots of a cut tree with his smartphone.

Arborist and conservationist Thomas Brail at a clearcutting near his hometown of Mazamet in the Tarn, France.

Melanie Jones, Jason Hoeksema, & Justine Karst

Over the past few years, a fascinating narrative about forests and fungi has captured the public imagination. It holds that the roots of neighboring trees can be connected by fungal filaments, forming massive underground networks that can span entire forests — a so-called wood-wide web. Through this web, the story goes, trees share carbon, water, and other nutrients, and even send chemical warnings of dangers such as insect attacks. The narrative — recounted in books, podcasts, TV series, documentaries, and news articles — has prompted some experts to rethink not only forest management but the relationships between self-interest and altruism in human society.

But is any of it true?

The three of us have studied forest fungi for our whole careers, and even we were surprised by some of the more extraordinary claims surfacing in the media about the wood-wide web. Thinking we had missed something, we thoroughly reviewed 26 field studies, including several of our own, that looked at the role fungal networks play in resource transfer in forests. What we found shows how easily confirmation bias, unchecked claims, and credulous news reporting can, over time, distort research findings beyond recognition. It should serve as a cautionary tale for scientists and journalists alike.

First, let’s be clear: Fungi do grow inside and on tree roots, forming a symbiosis called a mycorrhiza, or fungus-root. Mycorrhizae are essential for the normal growth of trees. Among other things, the fungi can take up from the soil, and transfer to the tree, nutrients that roots could not otherwise access. In return, fungi receive from the roots sugars they need to grow.

As fungal filaments spread out through forest soil, they will often, at least temporarily, physically connect the roots of two neighboring trees. The resulting system of interconnected tree roots is called a common mycorrhizal network, or CMN.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

You've reach your limit of free articles.

Get unlimited access to Worldcrunch

You can cancel anytime.

SUBSCRIBERS BENEFITS

Ad-free experience NEW

Exclusive international news coverage

Access to Worldcrunch archives

Monthly Access

30-day free trial, then $2.90 per month.

Annual Access BEST VALUE

$19.90 per year, save $14.90 compared to monthly billing.save $14.90.

Subscribe to Worldcrunch

The latest