Society

Play-Doh To Plato, A Case For Teaching Philosophy To Young Kids

Introducing deep thoughts to early child education can pay off later.

Big thoughts?
Caroline Stevan

GENEVA — "Who is God?" "And if he didn't create the earth, then who did?" "Why do some people believe in God and others don't?" "What was there before the Big Bang?" Children have an astounding capacity to ask, very early on, the most profound metaphysical questions. It is indeed a natural predisposition that we lose as the years go by.

This ability to be amazed, as well as a desire to understand, is a first step towards philosophy. That's why some deplore the fact that this subject isn't taught until the final years of schooling, and calls have begun to rise for philosophy classes to be introduced early in childhood.

"Learning to think is a difficult thing, a complex question by nature," says Edwige Chirouter, who was recently named to head the new UNESCO Chair on philosophy practice with children. "You need to start early. But the idea that philosophy is the subject that crowns off education has been prevailing since ancient times, so we only teach it very late in the school curriculum."

Chirouter insists that philosophy should be at the heart of all teaching subjects. "In history, we could ponder on the necessity to draw lessons from the past," she says. "In sciences, think about the notion of scientific truth."

Between 2005 and 2008, the French-born philosopher carried out an experiment in a primary school in western France, near Le Mans. She was impressed by the children's ability to appropriate philosophical topics, at their interest in the complexity of things. "Like us, they don't have many occasions to have a well-argued and serious discussion about the great questions of life. And they have intuitions: I found in what they were saying the theories defended by Kant, Rousseau, Heidegger," Chirouter recalls. "The most difficult part is to make them come out of their good pupil role, looking for the single right answer and waiting for the teacher's approval. In that aspect, children from less privileged backgrounds are less inhibited and end up doing better."

Philosophizing at four

One Geneva school, La Découverte (the Discovery), has been teaching philosophy to its young pupils for close to 20 years. All teachers are trained for that and the subject is introduced to children as young as 4 years old. Another will soon follow suit, in September. "We advocate active schooling, so it's logical to teach children how to think and not just how to learn," future headmistress Catherine Firmenich says. "Schools instill concepts, but are we asking ourselves to what end?"

Little Platos — Photo Les Petits Platons: Facebook group

Still in Geneva, the Public Instruction's Department decided to organize, together with the association ProPhilo, 360 workshops this year, for children aged 5 to 12, as part of the "living together" project. Philosophy implies dialogue and open-mindedness, virtues that also explain its current success.

"It's not philosophy's first goal, which is to reinforce discernment, but let's say that the social aspect is very important," says Alexandre Herriger, a teaching assistant specialized in philosophy for children and a member of the association ProPhilo.

"The stakes are also political. It's all the more important nowadays with the flow of information, the collapse of the great ideals and the rise of fanaticism. Philosophy, which is based on the acceptation that there is a plurality of responses, cannot be dogmatic," says Edwige Chirouter.

Primary schools in France, Belgium and Luxembourg now have introductory philosophy lessons as part of their citizenship classes. Jean-Paul Mongin, who published the children collection, Petits Platons (Little Platos), fears the subject might be perverted. "A lot of things are being done without sufficiently high standards," he says. "The risk is to fall into some sort of sanctimonious twaddle. Philosophy isn't a republican catechism of tolerance and companionship. On the contrary, it contains radical aspects and can lead to reflections of great violence. That said, one hour of discussion, even light-hearted, will always be better than one hour watching television."

Everybody agrees that philosophy practice is necessary to the education of children and responsible future citizens, but the methods differ. Some people who, like Alexandre Herriger, go to schools to talk to children about philosophy, start with a question that may or may not come from a pupil, while others rely on pictures or videos, and still others, following in the footsteps of American educator Matthew Lipman, believe that literature is the best ally. "Relying on a story enables you to give an issue a tangible substance, to unlock a plurality of possibilities and therefore to clarify its values," explains Chirouter. "It also introduces some distance between the subject and those who take part in the conversation."

A horse is a horse. Of course?

Classical literature can be a great starting point to discuss philosophical questions. "It's the Petits Platons' collection ambition," says Jean-Paul Mongin. So far, he has published about 30 books, translated in some 30 countries, that portray Epicurus and his relentless pursuit of happiness, the wise Socrates or Edith Stein's mighty fortress. Another collection, the recently launched Touts Petits Platons (Very Little Platos) is intended for even younger children, beginning at 4 years old, and aims at initiating the reflection process. The first volume, among other things, ponders on what would have happened if horses were instead called giraffes.

"The age of innocence grants younger children a freedom of examination that diminishes later, depending on what parents and school give them," says Francine Bouchet, who heads La Joie de Lire, another publisher that's now focusing on philosophy for the youngest. In the book Socrate et son papa (Socrates and his Dad), written by Einar Øverenget and Øyvind Torseter, a young boy wonders what happens to snowmen after winter or about the perception of clouds. "And this leads to asking ourselves about death or the view that shapes the world," Bouchet says.

So, what's the ideal age to start? According to most experts, the right time is around 6 or 7 years old, because only then can children think beyond themselves and put some emotional distance. "If you're talking about happiness, a very young child will talk about cuddling with his mother. Later on, he will articulate the regulation of desires," says author Frédéric Lenoir who just penned a book about meditation and children.

Lenoir says all children start out appreciating concepts of truth, justice, and values. "It's in their teenage years that this gets disrupted by peer pressure, the fear of being rejected, or other factors," he explains. "That's why it's important to start teaching philosophy at a young age, to fix these notions in their minds."

Support Worldcrunch
We are grateful for reader support to continue our unique mission of delivering in English the best international journalism, regardless of language or geography. Click here to contribute whatever you can. Merci!

La Sagrada Familia Delayed Again — Blame COVID-19 This Time

Hopes were dashed by local officials to see the completion of the iconic Barcelona church in 2026, in time for the 100th anniversary of the death of its renowned architect Antoni Guadí.

Work on La Sagrada Familia has been delayed because of the pandemic

By most accounts, it's currently the longest-running construction project in the world. And now, the completion of work on the iconic Barcelona church La Sagrada Familia, which began all the way back in 1882, is going to take even longer.

Barcelona-based daily El Periodico daily reports that work on the church, which began as the vision of master architect Antoni Gaudí, was slated to be completed in 2026. But a press conference Tuesday, Sep. 21 confirmed that the deadline won't be met, in part because of delays related to COVID-19. Officials also provided new details about the impending completion of the Mare de Déu tower (tower of the Virgin).

El Periódico - 09/22/2021

El Periodico daily reports on the latest delay from what may be the longest-running construction project in the world.

One tower after the other… Slowly but surely, La Sagrada Familia has been growing bigger and higher before Barcelonians and visitors' eager eyes for nearly 140 years. However, all will have to be a bit more patient before they see the famous architectural project finally completed. During Tuesday's press conference, general director of the Construction Board of the Sagrada Familia, Xavier Martínez, and the architect director, Jordi Faulí, had some good and bad news to share.

As feared, La Sagrada Familia's completion date has been delayed. Because of the pandemic, the halt put on the works in early March when Spain went into a national lockdown. So the hopes are dashed of the 2026 inauguration in what would have been the 100th anniversary of Gaudi's death.

Although he excluded new predictions of completion until post-COVID normalcy is restored - no earlier than 2024 -, Martínez says: "Finishing in 2030, rather than being a realistic forecast, would be an illusion, starting the construction process will not be easy," reports La Vanguardia.

But what's a few more years when you already have waited 139, after all? However delayed, the construction will reach another milestone very soon with the completion of the Mare de Déu tower (tower of the Virgin), the first tower of the temple to be completed in 44 years and the second tallest spire of the complex. It will be crowned by a 12-pointed star which will be illuminated on December 8, Immaculate Conception Day.

Next would be the completion of the Evangelist Lucas tower and eventually, the tower of Jesus Christ, the most prominent of the Sagrada Familia, reaching 172.5 meters thanks to an illuminated 13.5 meters wide "great cross." It will be made of glass and porcelain stoneware to reflect daylight and will be illuminated at night and project rays of light.

La Sagrada Familia through the years

La Sagrada Familia, 1889 - wikipedia

Support Worldcrunch
We are grateful for reader support to continue our unique mission of delivering in English the best international journalism, regardless of language or geography. Click here to contribute whatever you can. Merci!
THE LATEST
FOCUS
TRENDING TOPICS
MOST READ