PARIS — Sophie sighs as she watches Pierre-Alexis pace back and forth across the living room for the tenth time in an hour. “He can’t sit still for five minutes. Even when we’re watching a movie, he has to comment, guess the ending, and explain the historical references,” says the 42-year-old sales director with a touch of humor. “He has a knack for turning a Netflix evening into a lecture.”
For the past 15 years, she has been married to an engineer who was diagnosed with HPI [French acronym for “Haut potentiel intellectuel,” i.e. high intellectual potential, an alternative term for giftedness] at the age of 45. It was a late revelation that shed light on everything, but didn’t necessarily make things any easier. Because living with a High Intellectual Potential individual, far from the flattering clichés, can sometimes be a daily challenge.
For the latest news & views from every corner of the world, Worldcrunch Today is the only truly international newsletter. Sign up here.
People with these differently wired brains make up about 2% of the population and often turn married life into an emotional roller coaster. “Being HPI is not a medical condition, it’s more a unique way of thinking,” insists Béatrice Millêtre, a psychologist specializing in high potential. “Statistically, high-potential individuals fare better than others. They have academic intelligence, but also a different relationship with the world, both emotionally, socially, and interpersonally. They understand it better.”
Intensity as a way of life
Amélie, 38, an HR manager, gradually put the pieces together. Her husband Sylvain, an artistic director in the world of design, tackles projects with an energy that inspires admiration, but also a touch of annoyance, among his loved ones. “He starts three books at the same time, comes up with renovation ideas in the middle of the night, and plans vacations months in advance,” she says. “I feel like I’m constantly one step behind.”
This intellectual intensity is accompanied by a destabilizing emotional hypersensitivity. “HPIs think by association of ideas, in a tree structure, and with intensity: they can rise very high and fall very low,” explains Millêtre. “Overall, their senses are more acute, they are more alert, and their flow of thoughts is attuned to their feelings.”
Sylvain acknowledges this: “A simple sidelong glance from Amélie and I can start imagining disaster scenarios. She finds me exhausting, and she’s right.” This emotional hyperreactivity turns marital disputes into relational tsunamis. “It’s the apocalypse,” agrees Amélie. Sylvain then analyzes every word, dissects every silence, and blows every little detail out of proportion. A comment about the dishes can turn into a philosophical debate about the division of labor in patriarchal society. I end up avoiding conflict, simply to keep the peace.”
Fear of boredom
It might be the inability of HPIs to tolerate routine that puts the greatest strain on marital patience. “For a gifted person, routine is toxic,” confirms Béatrice Millêtre. “It’s impossible for them to stay on the sofa or a deck chair for very long on vacation. You can criticize them for not knowing how to relax, but it’s stronger than them.” Sophie has the bitter experience of this every summer: “Our vacations are hell. He has to visit three museums a day, taste local specialties, and talk to everyone. We’re never on the same wavelength. This unquenchable thirst for novelty turns into endless projects. He changes his mind as often as he changes his shirt. One weekend, he wants to renovate the kitchen; the next, he’s thinking about moving abroad. I feel like I’m living with a misguided teenager.”
HPI impulsivity adds an unpredictable dimension to this chronic instability. “If his brain works faster, he’ll answer before you finish your sentence because he’s already understood,” explains Millêtre. “They interrupt not out of rudeness, but to save time.”
As a result, I no longer dare to express my opinion on certain subjects.
Amélie confirms this trait: “He routinely anticipates what I’m going to say and finishes my stories for me. I sometimes feel like I’m ‘inferior,’ as if my slower mind irritates him.” This intellectual superiority, even if unclaimed, inevitably creates tension.
“The HPI may criticize a neurotypical person for not being interested in anything,” observes the psychologist. This form of condescension, even if unconscious, is difficult for a neurotypical partner to cope with in the long term: “He constantly corrects me,” Amélie laments. “Not out of malice, but because he can’t stand the approximation. As a result, I no longer dare to express my opinion on certain subjects.”
This intellectual demand is coupled with exhausting family perfectionism. “HPIs want to enrich their children by having them do lots of activities,” emphasizes Béatrice Millêtre. “This can be confusing for the spouse.” Sophie experiences this pressure on a daily basis: “Pierre-Alexis schedules every minute of Wednesday, when the children don’t have school: tennis, drawing, swimming, etc. The children are enthusiastic, but exhausted. When I express concern, he implies that I am encouraging mediocrity.“
When intelligence isolates
The paradox is that this intellectual richness can lead to emotional isolation. “Some feel misunderstood and decide to become aromantic,” observes Béatrice Millêtre. “They experience breakups as an emotional tsunami. And so they tend to value friendships over love.” David, 39, talks about his wife Nathalie’s emotional withdrawal: “She gradually closed herself off. She says I don’t understand her intellectually, that our conversations lack depth.” This quest for intensity in relationships can also translate into unusual sexuality. “They are either very sensual or, on the contrary, feel misunderstood,” notes the expert.
They have every ability to achieve well-being.
Faced with these challenges, mixed HPI-neurotypical couples develop varying coping strategies. “It’s not impossible for a neurotypical and an HPI to be in a relationship,” reassures Béatrice Millêtre. The key is not to try to change your partner or extrapolate from their behavior.“ It took David five years to understand how Nathalie works: ”I stopped taking it personally when she mentally zoning out in the middle of a conversation. Now I just say, ‘Where are you right now?’ and she comes back to our conversation.”
According to the psychologist, while it is essential to allow a gifted person to have moments of intense concentration and to give them space without stressing or stigmatizing them, they must in turn be careful not to show impatience or even contempt for neurotypical people, so that the couple can find a natural balance: “A highly gifted person must accept that those around them get tired more quickly than they do, allow them to relax and do nothing. Not to mention that they also need rest between episodes of hyperactivity, and the challenge is to adjust between these different phases in order to try to experience them together, at the same time.”
Life as a couple then becomes very satisfying, because the HP is a partner who will inspire you to do things. “This personality type is not doomed to unhappiness — quite the contrary,” concludes Millêtre. “They have every ability to achieve well-being.”
