When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Geopolitics

​Putin v. The West Began 16 Years Ago In Munich — And Nobody Noticed

The Munich Security Conference of 2023 takes place this weekend. The 2007 edition was a turning point for the world, where Vladimir Putin made his intentions clear — and today it all looks destined to arrive at the invasion of Ukraine.

Photo of Russian President Vladimir Putin giving a speech at the 43rd Annual Conference on Security Policy in Munich on Feb. 10, 2007.

Russian President Vladimir Putin speaking at the 43rd Annual Conference on Security Policy in Munich on Feb. 10, 2007.

Pierre Haski

-Analysis-

PARIS — The Munich Security Conference, which runs through Sunday, has often been described as the "Davos of Defense," where generals take the stage instead of CEOs. It is also where, 16 years ago, Vladimir Putin made it clear to the world that he would invade Ukraine.

This is obviously an oversimplification. Still, it's worth returning to the Munich Conference of 2007 when the Russian President announced to the West that the post-Soviet party was over.

Stay up-to-date with the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war, with our exclusive international coverage.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter.

Putin delivered a brutal and cutting speech in the German city that was largely overlooked at the time. He had already been in power for seven years, had led the war in Chechnya, and stabilized the situation in Russia after the tumultuous 1990s. By 2007, he was ready to tell the West how he really saw the world.

He launched a scathing critique of the unipolar world, led by the sole superpower at the time, the United States, after the collapse of the Soviet Union. "It is a world of one master, one sovereign," he said.


And for the first time, he denounced NATO's expansion to the East, declaring: "We are legitimately entitled to openly ask against whom this expansion is being carried out."

What's Putin thinking

As observed by Andrei Grachev, a longtime spokesman for Mikhail Gorbachev: "Everyone then considered Putin a lame duck. His speech in Munich was not taken too seriously."

Grachev, who is no fan of Putin's, returned to that fateful speech in his recent book The World Will Never Be The Same Again.: "Few participants that day understood that it was not the voice of a man of the past, nostalgic for a bygone era, but the cry of a new version of Putin 2.0 threatening a new war."

The following year, the war broke out in Georgia.

The pragmatist became an ideologue.

For almost a year now, since he made the fateful decision to invade Ukraine, everyone has been asking "what is in Vladimir Putin's head?" And in parallel, we wonder how the Russian population reacts.

Grachev writes that Putin chose to respond to the Russian people's distress in facing the Soviet collapse by "mobilizing the people behind their leader in the fight for the restoration of historical justice and the deserved greatness of the country."

"Becoming official," he adds, "this ideology was the origin of a radical turning point in Putin's domestic policy towards a confrontation with the West. The pragmatist thus became an ideologue."

Strategic error

Grachev does not spare the West, which he says was guilty of arrogance towards Russia at the time of the collapse of the communist bloc, and its true "strategic error" in refusing to create a collective security structure integrating Russia.

The resolute West has now understood Putin's message.

But he explains well how Putin's transformation is above all a matter of power, how he aims to put the country and the world in a state of permanent tension, as a kind of system rather than an instrument to use when needed.

This framework makes sense as the war in Ukraine drags into a long war. In the absence of any Russian representative this year, the Munich Conference will not have time to reconsider missed opportunities before and after 2007. Yet the West stands resolute, having now understood that Putin wants confrontation.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

FOCUS: Russia-Ukraine War

How Much Does Xi Jinping Care About Putin's ICC Arrest Warrant?

After the International Criminal Court issued an arrest warrant for Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping arrives in Moscow for a three-day visit. How far will he be willing to go to support Putin, a fugitive from international justice?

Photo of Russian President Vladimir Putin and Interior Minister Vladimir Kolokoltsev

Extended meeting of Russian Interior Ministry board on Monday, March 20

Pierre Haski

-Analysis-

PARIS — Since Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin said last year that the friendship between their nations was "boundless," the world has wondered where the limits really lie. The Chinese president's three-day visit to Russia, which began Monday, gives us an opportunity to assess.

Xi's visit is important in many ways, particularly because the International Criminal Court has just issued an arrest warrant against Putin for his role in forcibly sending thousands of Ukrainian children to Russia. For Putin, there could be no better response to this international court, which he does not recognize, than to appear alongside the president of a great country, which, like Russia, is also a permanent member of the UN Security Council. How isolated can Putin really be, when the leader of 1.5 billion people in China comes to visit?

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest