When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Already a subscriber? Log in .

You've reached your limit of one free article.

Get unlimited access to Worldcrunch

You can cancel anytime .


Exclusive International news coverage

Ad-free experience NEW

Weekly digital Magazine NEW

9 daily & weekly Newsletters

Access to Worldcrunch archives

Free trial

30-days free access, then $2.90
per month.

Annual Access BEST VALUE

$19.90 per year, save $14.90 compared to monthly billing.save $14.90.

Subscribe to Worldcrunch

Bali Artists Fight Project With Whiff Of Disney And Dubai

Artists protesting against development projects in Bali
Artists protesting against development projects in Bali
Nicole Curby

BALI — In the Indonesian resort island of Bali, music hasn't always been political. But news of a Dubai-style development has galvanized local musicians and artists.

The development involves reclaiming 700 hectares of Benoa Bay in southern Bali to make way for a string of artificial islands complete with resorts, shopping centers, theme parks and high-end apartments. A consequent tolak reklamasi or "reject reclamation" movement has inspired protest songs like one by the folk band Nosstress.

Copok, a singer and guitarist for the local band The Bullhead, explains why residents are against the development. "They will put culture on the island but it will be a plastic culture. We have real culture. It is buildings and people. They have artificial culture. They claim that all of Bali is there like Indonesia Miniature Park or Walt Disney," Copok says.

Since the project was first approved by the Indonesian government in December 2012, a mass movement has been gathering steam. Across the island, vibrant banners are strung up at traffic intersections and street corners with the "reject reclamation" slogan.

Demonstrations take over the streets on a regular basis, music concerts and art events campaign against the development, and now communities across the island are compiling an album of protest songs sung by local children.

Copok says it's crucial that people understand what the development means. "This movement is purely to save your home. The developer promises heaven, but the surroundings will be destroyed," Copok explains.

At the Taman Baca garden and library, a hangout for the movement's volunteers, activists imagine a different future for Bali — one where excessive development can be curtailed.

"People use art to move and fight against the government, against the investor. We make an event using art, music, go-go dancing, drawing, mural art, street art. And other young people who don't know about it become interested. What is this? What are they talking about?" explains Adi Apriyanta Parma, a Balinese student.

Ketut Putra, the vice president of Conservation International in Indonesia, says activists want to ensure there's no harm to the environment or local culture. "We don't reject development, we love development. But we need to design the development that we want to minimize or even have no impact at all on our environment, on our culture," Putra says.

The project is being developed by Tirta Wahana Bali International, a company controlled by influential Indonesian businessman Tommy Winata.

The company promised that the project will be environmentally responsible and culturally sensitive in an area that has at least 70 sacred Hindu sites. But the environmental impact of building artificial islands will be devastating, says Putra. "From the perspective of, for example, fisheries, the reclamation may potentially reduce or even fully alter the entire coastal habitats for 80% of marine species we have in Bali," he says.

Since the movement gained traction, police have warned musicians like Sony Bono of the band Nymphea not to mention the project at their gigs.

Authorities had also banned discussion of the development at an international event and beat up peaceful demonstrators in the past. But Bono refuses to be intimated despite what he describes as an overwhelming culture of silence in Bali.

[rebelmouse-image 27090335 alt="""" original_size="740x416" expand=1]

A sign for "Reject reclamation" movement Photo: Nicole Curby

"We call it, koh ngomong ... In English language, ‘I don't want to talk about it.' It's become our habit. So with us musicians, we try to break that habit. So maybe if we use our language — music, through music we can break that habit," Bono says.

The protest had largely been carried out by Bali's youth as older residents were initially reluctant to speak out. About 80,000 Balinese are estimated to have been killed in the communist massacres in 1965 and 1966, and those events are still remembered, Parma says. "Everything the government says, the old people only say "yes' and "ok," "yes' and "ok." They are afraid history will repeat again. The young people try to fight against that, you know," he adds.

But now things are changing. Many people from older generations added their weight to the campaign earlier this year — four years after the movement first began. Balinese are now pressuring the Indonesian administration to step in and stop the project.

If the Environmental Impact Assessment currently under review is accepted, the project will get the go ahead for construction. Residents agree this is an important year for Bali's future.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.


Why The U.S. Trade Blockade Can't Stop China's Sprint For All-Powerful AI

If computing power becomes a major tool for superpowers like China and the U.S., then what does the latest U.S. technology blockade mean for the race to a more powerful AI? Honk Kong-based daily The Initium looks at the nuclear race of our time, with chips as the modern-day equivalent of enriched uranium.

Technicians examine mobile phone chips at a manufacture plant in Jiujiang, east China's Jiangxi Province​

JIUJIANG, Dec. 12, 2010 Technicians examine mobile phone chips at a manufacture plant in Jiujiang, east China's Jiangxi Province

Hu Guolin/ZUMA
Yang Lu


The latest restrictions introduced by the U.S. Department of Commerce Bureau of Industry and Security to regulate exports of advanced technology represent not only a milestone for U.S.-China relations, but also a watershed for the current state of science and technology in the world.

The U.S. Advanced Computing/Supercomputing Interim Final Rule and the corresponding Semiconductor Manufacturing Equipment Interim Final Rule, which were announced on Oct. 16 of this year, are much more restrictive compared to the previous export rules released on Oct. 7, 2022.

For the latest news & views from every corner of the world, Worldcrunch Today is the only truly international newsletter. Sign up here.

One of the major players affected by these rules is NVIDIA, an American tech firm that designs and sells graphics processing units (GPUs) — processors that can go through many pieces of data simultaneously, making them useful for machine learning, gaming, and cryptocurrency mining. The company found a gap and launched a new China-specific version of the chip.

But the U.S. Commerce Secretary issued a warning for NDVIA and declared that the cut lines of control in the future will move frequently, and the room for companies to maneuver will only get smaller and smaller. This means that the overall performance of NVIDIA chips that Chinese users can buy will only get worse in the future.

With ChatGPT being a major turning point, the future of AI development will be divided into two different paths: the GPU rich, and the GPU poor.

Keep reading...Show less

The latest