MADA MASR

As Fuel Prices Rise, Egyptians Turn To Alternative Transport

Since the Egyptian government cut fuel subsidies earlier this year, the cost of fuel has hit working Egyptians where it hurts. Carpooling and even bus-pooling are gaining steam.

Waiting at Cairo's Shobra Al-Khaima metro station
Waiting at Cairo's Shobra Al-Khaima metro station
Passant Rabie

CAIRO — KarTag, a mobile phone application designed to help people organize carpools through their networks of Facebook friends, was launched in May 2013, but initially found little success. A little over a year later, the government announced it would lift fuel subsidies, causing an increase in private transportation fares on microbuses and taxis.

Suddenly, KarTag witnessed a 20% increase in downloads. Ahmed Saad, co-founder of the company, had been trying to convince people to carpool for months, but at the end of the day, "money is what hurts," he says.

For years, Egyptians have been enjoying the perks of subsidized fuel prices, which have determined their long-standing commuting habits. According to a Bloomberg study earlier this year, Egypt ranked 58th of 61 countries in terms of lowest global gas prices.

Today, fuel price hikes have affected everyone, not just the 14% of households that own cars. The majority, who rely on private transportation such as microbuses or taxis, have also been impacted by tariff increases and the rising costs of everyday commodities. As a result, some are looking for alternative, cost-saving means of transportation, while others are finding fewer alternatives.

Najlaa Abdel Bary, who lives in Maadi and has to drive during the week to Mohandiseen for her job as a documentation officer, says that since gas prices went up, she has been parking her Skoda closer to alternative means of transportation. After leaving her car, she often takes the Metro and then a taxi to get to the office, as there are no Metro stations nearby. But she says that she also has to be careful when taking the metro to avoid overcrowding.

"The car was more comfortable, of course," she says. "The Metro seems like a viable option, but it requires a dress code for me … and taxi fares are getting insanely high, sometimes double what it used to cost, since people stopped going by the meter."

Public transport less of an option for women

For Abdel Bary, ithe cost of fuel is not all that has gone up. Also costlier now are parking, medicine and food, which requires her to ration her spending. But because public transport is inconvenient and sexual harassment pervasive, Abdel Bary is considering selling her Skoda and buying a more fuel-efficient car instead.

Mohamed Mostafa, who lives in the crowded neighborhood of Nasr City, also refuses to give up his car as the main means of transport. "I use my car to go on long trips, and I hate public transportation in Egypt, so the new gas prices have definitely affected my lifestyle a bit," he says.

Ahmed Dorghamy, an environmental consultant and co-founder of the Green Arm non-governmental organization, explains that with the new gas prices, people are going through what he refers to as "trip chaining" — whereby you start reducing the number of trips based on time or money constraints.

"More planning is good because it reduces energy consumption, and also good socially because you do more things with more people, but you lose flexibility," he adds.

The Carpooling Egypt Facebook page is a closed group of around 500 people, founded by Ahmed Korayem after the gas prices went up. He saw it as an opportunity to get people to buy into the concept of carpooling. Korayem says that he has been carpooling for a long time, accompanying friends and strangers alike on trips from Heliopolis to Smart Village or Zamalek.

"It's a small community, but it's definitely catching on. The fuel price hikes might be a motive," he says.

Korayem created the Facebook group one night and woke up the next morning to find that more than 300 people had joined, which is when he decided to keep it closed to maintain a small network. He says that he has received requests from people to join the group, but he first scans their Facebook profiles to make sure they don't pose a threat to other group members.

One of the reasons why people shy away from carpooling in Egypt is because of fear of riding with strangers, which violates social norms. On the other hand, Dorghamy explains, car owners in Egypt are not likely to switch to public transportation and abandon their cars, particularly women, who fear sexual harassment. Driving a car is associated with a certain social class, and there is a stigma attached to using public transportation, he adds.

This is where initiatives such as Bus Pooling have come into play, offering people the convenience of not having to drive while still charging a high monthly fee of 800 Egyptian pounds to maintain a certain social standard.

"Bus Pooling"

Bus Pooling was founded in May 2013 as a way to gather people heading to a common destination into a rented bus. The company re-launched after the fuel price hikes and saw requests double in under three weeks.

"People want to be at ease and comfortable," says co-founder Mohamed Ehab. "We're targeting a different group with a high-quality service." But, he notes, changing people's habits is difficult. "It's not something we're raised with, and people are apprehensive of riding with someone they don't know."

Dorghamy suggests further study to better understand what each segment of the market needs to encourage people to change their commuting habits.

Others have discovered public transportation to be more efficient than their prior means of transportation. At the recently opened Koleyet Banat Metro station in the Cairo neighborhood of Heliopolis, Mostafa Mahmoud and Ahmed Mohamed are making their way to catch the next train home.

The two used to rely on private transportation, such as taxis or microbuses, but both have seen a significant increase in fares over the last period. "Of course, we had to change our habits," says Mohamed. "The ticket to ride the Metro is only one Egyptian pound, compared to more than double what we would have had to pay for a microbus, and it's one line that takes me straight home rather than having to take several buses."

Aside from the cost, Mahmoud says the Metro is overall more convenient. "You usually have to wait an hour or an hour and a half for private transportation, and then go through additional hours of traffic, but the Metro is efficient. You get to work on time," says Mahmoud.

But for those outside Cairo, the efficiency and convenience of the new Metro lines is not an option.

Ahmed Aly from Alexandria says he must keep using private transportation, such as microbuses and taxis, even though the fares have increased by at least 40%.

"I haven’t changed my habits," he says. "I still use private transport because I’m forced to stick to it," he says.

Dorghamy attests to the affordability of public transportation in Egypt, but says it should have been invested in more. He says that fuel hikes in Cuba prompted the opening of new factories to manufacture buses. They also split schools to cut travel distances.

According to a study conducted by Dorghamy's organization, 200 new cars are hitting the roads each year. The government is making room for more vehicles, as it expands roads and builds new bridges, resulting in the equivalent loss of four football fields of public space every week.

But unfortunately, Egyptians are not commonly exploring alternate options for transportation, such as walking or cycling.

Cycling gets a slow embrace

Mohamed al-Masry, a member of the group Be Cyclist, which teaches people how to ride bicycles, says that even though there has been a slight increase in people interested to learn, they tend to do it for recreation.

The percentage of people learning how to cycle with the group increased after President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi's initiative to encourage people to ride bicycles. Be Cyclist is working towards encouraging people to use bicycles instead of cars, advising them that an hour and a half of traffic can be cycled in less than half an hour.

With gas costs higher, people are more responsive. "You can make the best out of it, and end up having less air pollution," Dorghamy says.

Environmentalists say there is a global shift from private vehicles to public transportation or other alternatives, particularly in Europe, where people have begun abandoning their cars.

For this to happen in Egypt, Dorghamy believes people need to let go of the social stigma related to transportation. Perhaps the increase in gas prices is the push people need.

Keep up with the world. Break out of the bubble.
Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter!
Society

How Low Trust In Government Fuels Violence Against Politicians

The deadly stabbing of UK MP David Amess confirms this researcher's ongoing study on trust and governance in democracies around the world: It's bad.

Tribute to slain UK MP David Amess in Leigh-on-Sea on Oct. 15

James Weinberg

The killing of British Conservative MP David Amess, who was stabbed to death in his constituency on October 15, is a tragic moment for democracy. What makes it even more devastating is that such a catastrophic failure is not without precedent or predictability. Labour MP Jo Cox was shot at her constituency surgery in 2016. Before her, another Labour MP, Stephen Timms, survived a stabbing in 2010. And Andrew Pennington, a Gloucestershire county councillor, died in a frenzied attack in 2001 while trying to protect local Liberal Democrat MP Nigel Jones.

This is to say nothing of the 2018 attack on the Palace of Westminster that left police officer Keith Palmer dead and MPs in a state of shock.

Beyond these critical junctures in the public debate about politicians' safety, elected representatives must live with an increasingly insidious level of popular cynicism that threatens violence on an almost daily basis.


Between the divisive politics of Brexit and the growing polarization of British party politics, MPs currently work in a low-trust, high-blame environment. Even before the existential angst and subsequent politicking of the COVID-19 pandemic, a recent Hansard Society audit of political engagement concluded that “opinions of the systems of governing are at their lowest point in the 15-year Audit series – worse now than in the aftermath of the MPs' expenses scandal."

The ramifications of governing in such an age of distrust are significant for the mental health and wellbeing of politicians. With colleagues, I've argued that such visceral and endemic distrust is a key stressor in political life. People are not simply wary or skeptical of politicians, they now routinely criticize their personalities and dismiss their good intentions. At its most severe, this “distrust stressor" manifests in the growing threat of physical violence faced by politicians.

Unfortunately, the distrust stressor is commonplace in the febrile climate of post-millennial UK politics. Serious cases of stalking and harassment have become a “common experience" for MPs. In the UK general election of 2017, for example, 56% of surveyed parliamentary candidates expressed concern about the levels of abuse and intimidation they had received and 31% said they had felt “fearful" during the campaign. Misuse of anonymous social media accounts has intensified these problems and created a toxic environment for elected politicians that regularly exposes them to online rape and murder threats.

Governing under threat

As part of an ongoing study of trust and governance in five democracies around the world, I recently carried out more than 50 in-depth interviews with junior and senior politicians in national legislatures, including questions on the stresses and strains of political life.

Reflecting on the ramifications of simply doing their job, one Conservative MP commented:

There have been votes that have been controversial, and you can then get a lot of abuse as a result of picking a side. My office has been vandalized, I've had stuff sent to me in the post, I've received death threats. And you do build up a very thick skin doing this job, there's no shadow of a doubt. Because one week in it, if you're not able to roll with the punches, you won't see through a whole term.

Almost 40% of interviewees were able to cite more than one instance of serious abuse or threats of physical violence. Not only are these experiences felt across both sides of the political aisle in the UK, but they also appear to be growing more common in other democratic contexts where the climate of politics has been presumed to be both calmer and more volatile. As one MP in New Zealand told me:

I've had some pretty horrible death threats and I've had a lot of abuse, particularly through social media. But also, funnily enough, in writing and phone calls. Unfortunately it's becoming more part of our political life.

Another, this time in South Africa, said:

What [this group of constituents] were saying is that if the water supply was not fixed by a certain time, they were going to kill me. And what they did is they took a tyre and said that this tyre was going to go around my neck and they're going to light it and that was going to be my demise. Listen, when you see your life flash before your eyes… you start to question whether it's worth it.

In the UK, analysis of data from the Representative Audit of Britain (a survey of all parliamentary candidates who stood in general elections between 2015 and 2019) suggests that the harassment, abuse and intimidation of elected and aspiring politicians is also highly gendered. Women politicians, and black and minority ethnic women in particular, experience a disproportionate share of sexualized abuse online. They also receive more aggressive and sexualized threats offline.

Contact between politicians and the public is at the very heart of effective democratic representation.

It is relatively easy to understand why all this would be detrimental to politicians' professional competence and their sense of personal worth and wellbeing, but it is harder to find solutions to this crisis.

Home Secretary Priti Patel has called for increased security measures in the wake of Amess's death. This is welcome but it's an instrumental response which might not be easy to implement. Political contact between politicians and the public is at the very heart of effective democratic representation – and it is unlikely that most MPs will agree to suspend constituency surgeries or fill their offices with armed guards at a time when governor-governed relations are already so strained.

Photo of \u200bNew Zealand's parliament in Wellington

New Zealand's parliament in Wellington

Guo Lei/Xinhua/ZUMA

Compassion and education

While specific issues around MPs' security and training are grappled with, we also need a call for conscious restraint and compassion in political discourse. When some politicians themselves resort to dog-whistle populism, verbal abuse and infighting, it broadcasts an image of politics as an arena for incivility. At the same time, it perpetuates a binary worldview that crowds out the possibility of empathy and compromise.

Alongside this, we need to overhaul the media coverage of politics. Increasingly intent on personalizing the political and politicizing the personal, a 24-hour news media too often drip feeds blunt stereotypes about politicians' personalities and motives. In contrast to much news coverage of politicians, my own research with hundreds of elected MPs and councillors has shown that the majority enter politics with an extraordinary dedication to improving the lives of others that is rarely perceived or appreciated by those they govern.

A deficit in democratic education leads to inflated public expectations about what is possible.

Equally important, nations around the world must commit to fully funded and well-resourced programmes of democratic education. Politics is messy and full of contingencies, and a deficit in democratic education leads to inflated public expectations about what is possible or desirable. In turn, this breeds disappointment and lowered self-efficacy, which together disrupt the positive potential of deliberative participation.

Ultimately, there is no place for political violence, harassment or intimidation in a functioning democracy. At the very least, politicians are ordinary humans attempting to undertake an extraordinary job on behalf of everybody else. Whatever their political views, nobody who has the courage to "step into the arena", to paraphrase Theodore Roosevelt, deserves to fear for their life in the pursuit of public service. To say that we need to rediscover civility and respect in our politics is once again an understatement of a devastating truth.The Conversation

--------------------------------------------

James Weinberg is a lecturer in Political Behavior at the University of Sheffield

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Keep up with the world. Break out of the bubble.
Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter!
THE LATEST
FOCUS
TRENDING TOPICS
MOST READ