When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Geopolitics

No, The West Is Not In Decline

Europe, the United States and other parts of the so-called West may not be booming, but they're not about to be superseded either. Quite the contrary, in fact.

Holding steady
Holding steady
Yves Montenay

-OpEd-

PARIS — Let's begin by clarifying what we mean by "West." The Western world is an intellectual, economic and military ensemble gathering Western and Central Europe, North America, Australia, New Zealand and Israel. And, now, Japan.

Demography

The proportion of Western population in the world is decreasing, it's true. But that's also the case for China and Russia. India, where areas of low fertility rates are spreading, will likely follow suit.

On the demographic level, the West is not, therefore, being replaced by Asia. Both instead are being pushed by Africa. That said, Africa isn't an economic, military or cultural rival for the West, so its demographic growth in no way represents a decline of the West.

Economy and Military

Is the West declining economically? After its concern late last century regarding the rise of Japan and other Asian Tigers, it's now worried about Chinese expansion. And yet, China's very real catch-up is coming to an end, and the next step will be a slow and difficult one. Its authoritarian regime will inevitably restrict innovations to the benefit of insider interests.

With 22% of the world population, it's only natural that China recovers a certain rank in the global economy. But that doesn't make it a cause of economic decline for the West.

Let's not forget that all developing countries systematically copy the West. And they do so by reproducing — if not stealing — its technical formulas as well as its legal, managerial, and educational organizations. This is anything but a sign of decline.

What about India? It's a country that's deeply paralyzed ethnically, religiously, socially and bureaucratically. Cows there get a better pension than farmers; fiscal barriers between states hinder trade; roads and electricity are lacking ... Sure, things are finally getting better in India, and it will probably become a very important client; but it's far from being a new China. As for Africa, the future demographic giant is extremely weak economically, despite showing a few encouraging signs.

The West remains, in comparison to its competitors, very creative and economically attractive for investors and entrepreneurs the world over. Its standard of living is still the highest in the world — by a huge margin. The United States military budget is four times bigger than China's and 10 times bigger than Russia's, even though mistakes in economic management or military strategy sometimes make us forget that.

Culture

Western culture provides a decisive advantage, including on the economic level, through the individual, political and religious freedom it allows. The resulting intellectual energy created, fueled by permanent reflection and self-criticism, is an unmatchable strength.

[rebelmouse-image 27090442 alt="""" original_size="640x425" expand=1]

Checking in — Photo: Luca Sartoni

And this isn't just about the media or the entertainment industry. Of course, these are important, especially for the U.S. and its champions (Hollywood, Facebook, Amazon, etc.), as it gives them an undeniable influence. It's about much more than that: The West is a unique and complex product.

As French philosopher Philippe Nemo rightly put it in his book What is the West?, it's a combination of Ancient Greece and Roman legalism, of a vision of the world shaped first by early Christianity, then later by the Gregorian Reform, the Renaissance, Protestantism and the Enlightenment, all leading to our liberal democracy, a framework that allows for a free and innovative intellectual life.

The West wouldn't have needed colonialism to establish itself. Whenever they're in contact with the West, populations invariably choose it. For the same reasons, it is despised by dictators or traditionalists, especially now Islamists, and their accusations of imperialism and decadence are convenient tools to help them contain that influence.

Japan has become part of the Western world because it's a liberal democracy where individuals, and not only practices, have westernized. In China, an authoritarian regime, leaders do their utmost to prevent this from happening— blocking the Internet and throwing those who have been "contaminated" in jail.

Languages, finally, play their part in the process. English, French, Spanish, Portuguese are all spoken in vast parts of the world, whereas Mandarin Chinese and Hindi, despite their great number of speakers, remain regional languages.

And as for Africa, let's not forget that despite its growing demographic importance, its cultural capital cities are actually Paris, London or New York. This isn't neocolonialism; it's about the opportunities we bring to that continent.

The West isn't declining. On the contrary, the rest of the world is westernizing.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Geopolitics

With The Chechen War Veterans Fighting For Ukraine — And For Revenge

They came to fight Russia, and to avenge the deaths of their loved ones and friends killed in Chechnya. Not wanting to sit in the trenches, they've found work in intelligence and sabotage.

Photo of members of the pro-Ukrainian Chechen group "Dzhokhar Dudayev Battalion" posing with weapons

Members of the pro-Ukrainian Chechen group "Dzhokhar Dudayev Battalion"

Lydia Mikhalchenko

At least five Chechen units are fighting for Ukraine, with more than 1,000 troops in each unit — and their number is growing.

Most of these Chechen fighters took part in the first and second Chechen wars with Russia, and were forced to flee to Ukraine or elsewhere in Europe after their defeat. Vazhnyye Istorii correspondent Lydia Mikhalchenko met with some of these fighters.

Four of the five Chechen battalions are part of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, and are paid the standard wages (about €4,000 per month for those on the front line) and receive equipment and supplies.

Chechen fighters say they appreciate that Ukrainian commanders don't order them to take unnecessary risks and attack objectives just to line up with an unrealistic schedule or important dates — something Russian generals are fond of doing.

Stay up-to-date with the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war, with our exclusive international coverage.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter.

The experienced Chechen fighters have taken fewer losses than many other units. Unhappy sitting in trenches, they mostly engage in reconnaissance and sabotage, moving along the front lines. "The Russians wake up, and the commander is gone. Or he's dead," one of the fighters explains.

Some of the fighters say that the Ukrainian war is easier than their previous battles in Chechnya, when they had to sit in the mountains for weeks without supplies and make do with small stocks of arms and ammunition. Some call this a "five-star war."

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest