When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Israel

In Israel, Where Child Care Is A Prime Barometer Of Economic Squeeze

In Tel Aviv
In Tel Aviv
Gil Kelian

TEL AVIV — The school year is starting soon, and with it comes another not-so-small burden on families around Israel: pre-school and pre-elementary education can cost up to one-third of a person's gross salary, even in upper-income cities and towns.

Indeed, child care expenses for young families was a central point of contention during the 2011 social protests centered in Tel Aviv — Israel's largely middle-class version of the Indignados movement challenging economic policy around the West. And while that movement has largely faded, an investigation by Calcalist shows that the financial burden of early education on Israeli families has not.

An analysis of child care, nursery school and kindergarten prices in different cities compared to the average gross salary of workers in those cities, shows that the cost of education represents one-quarter to one-third of family income. When compared to net income, the proportion of education costs would be even higher.

The analysis was conducted in 14 cities, based on the average of the most expensive and cheapest nursery and kindergarten prices, and on the average salary of the city. In eight out of the 14 cities, the prices represent 30% or more of gross pay. Furthermore, it seems that there is no major difference between poorer and wealthier: In the cities where school costs less, the salary is lower as well.

In Petah-Tikva for instance, pre-elementary school costs 2,400-3,000 shekels ($670-$840) and the average salary is around 9,000 shekels ($2,525) a month. On the other hand in Ashdod, the school costs 1,800-2,400 shekels ($500- 670), but the average salary is also lower: 7,330 shekels ($2,050). In both cities, despite the considerable difference in the average salary, the early education costs represents exactly 30% of monthly income.

In five other cities, pre-elementary education costs up to one-quarter of the average salary, even when the prices are relatively cheap. Without forgetting that those prices are for one child: Families with twins or two young children weigh doubly on the parents’ income.

[rebelmouse-image 27087304 alt="""" original_size="499x312" expand=1]

In Jerusalem - Photo: David Soto-Karlin

Only in Modi’in is the cost of child care lower (18%): The pre-school and kindergartens are not cheap (around $700), but the salaries are high ($3700)

In Tel Aviv, the cost represents 31% of the average salary. In Haifa 32%, Netanya 33%, Beersheba 28%.

A complicated market

The opening of many public facilities for kids aged three and older (a result of the 2011 social protests) have helped ease up the burden, but for younger children it is still difficult to find subsidized structures like Wizo or Naamat, so families have to turn to private and more expensive nursery schools and kindergartens.

“The main contributor to the cost is labor," says Hanan Dagan, chairman of the union for child-care workers. "For every five or six children, there is a caregiver." Doing the math, this means that if a caregiver or teacher's monthly salary is 5,000 shekels ($1,400), the cost to the facility is 6,500 ($1,800), which means 1,000 shekels ($280) per child.

"And these prices are for the periphery," Dagan adds. "In the city center, the cost of the same caregiver can go up to tens of thousands of shekels.”

To that you have to add the maintenance of the facility, including rent and taxes. Dagan says there is no way to break this market, “because if you break it, you lose. All along this past year we have heard of many schools that reached a situation of near bankruptcy, and I'm talking about good, well-established facilities."

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Geopolitics

Cilia Flores de Maduro, How Venezuela's First Lady Wields A Corrupt "Flower Shop" Of Power

Venezuela's first lady, Cilia Flores, is one of the country's chief power brokers and a consummate wheeler-dealer who, with the help of relatives, runs a voracious enterprise dubbed the Flower Shop.

Photo of Cilia Flores (left) and her husband Nicolás Maduro (middle)

Cilia Flores (left) and her husband Nicolás Maduro (middle)

Mauricio Rubio

-OpEd-

One of the clearest signs of tyranny in Venezuela has to be the pervasive nepotism and behind-the-scenes power enjoyed by President Nicolás Maduro's wife, Cilia Flores de Maduro.

In Venezuela, it's said that Flores works in the shadows but is somehow "always in the right place," with one commentator observing that she is constantly "surrounded by an extensive web of collaborators" — including relatives, with whom she has forged a clique often dubbed the floristería, or the "Flower Shop," which is thought to control every facet of Venezuelan politics.

She is certainly Venezuela's most powerful woman.

From modest origins, Flores is 68 years old and a lawyer by training. She began her ascent as defense attorney for the then lieutenant-colonel Hugo Chávez, who was jailed after his failed attempt at a coup d'état in 1992. She offered him her services and obtained his release, which won her his unstinting support for the rest of his life.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest