When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Already a subscriber? Log in .

You've reached your limit of one free article.

Get unlimited access to Worldcrunch

You can cancel anytime .


Exclusive International news coverage

Ad-free experience NEW

Weekly digital Magazine NEW

9 daily & weekly Newsletters

Access to Worldcrunch archives

Free trial

30-days free access, then $2.90
per month.

Annual Access BEST VALUE

$19.90 per year, save $14.90 compared to monthly billing.save $14.90.

Subscribe to Worldcrunch

India Higher Education Inferior Complex: Where Are The Foreign University Campuses?

The proposed UGC guidelines are ill-conceived and populist, and hardly take note of the educational and financial interests of foreign universities.

Image of a group of five people sitting on the grass inside of the Indian Institute of Technology campus.

The IIT - Indian Institute of Technology - Campus

M.M Ansari and Mohammad Naushad Khan

NEW DELHI — Nearly 800,000 young people from India attend foreign universities every year in search of quality education and entrepreneurial training, resulting in a massive outflow of resources – $3 billion – to finance their education. These students look for greener pastures abroad because of the lack of quality teaching and research in most of India’s higher education institutions.

Over 40,000 colleges and 1,000 universities are producing unemployable graduates who cannot function in a knowledge- and technology-intensive economy.

The Indian government's solution is to open doors to foreign universities, with a proposed set of regulations aiming to provide higher education and research services to match global standards, and to control the outflow of resources. But this decision raises many questions.

Surprisingly, while promoting social justice and welfare through university and college quotas for students from poorer families, the government has made this decision without any limit on the fee structure. Education experts and academics are concerned that opening the doors to foreign universities may further strengthen the commercialization of education, and that decades down the line, it may overshadow our educational models and encroach on our educational system.

A social welfare activity

There is no denying that the presence of foreign universities may have some advantages, but we have to weigh what disadvantages it may cause in the short and long run. Can we envision creating Indian Institutes of Technology and Indian Institutes of Management campuses with the same rules abroad?

But we see no corresponding gains to India’s economy from these highly educated and trained students. Most job seekers seek placements in multinational corporations with higher earnings, and therefore, they do not return to the country.

Foreign universities don’t see India as an attractive destination.

Another concern raised by pedagogues: the idea that education in India is largely a social welfare activity, for which the government has made an oft-repeated commitment to allocate at least 6% of the GDP (although currently less than 3% of the GDP is spent on education).

While several private educational institutions offer diploma or degree programs as a social service, they are not permitted to commercialize education or earn profits. Why?

A group of young graduates in orange robes throwing des caps in the air, in front of the Indian Institute of Technology Campus

Young graduates of the Indian Institute of Technology in Delhi.

IIT Facebook page

No gains for the universities' funders

Though the Supreme Court of India prohibits profit-making in education, there are many private institutions under the patronage of large companies and top political leaders who use accounting gimmicks to skirt tax laws and make money. Is this what India expects foreign universities to do in the country?

In such an educational environment, in which the private education lobby is so strong and can flourish despite a ban on profit-making, foreign universities don’t see India as an attractive destination.

Now, the question is, why should a top foreign university, say Harvard or Oxford, supported by donors and taxpayers, provide a charity service in India, without tangible gains to its funders?

The proposed guidelines by the University Grants Commission (UGC) do not commit to providing physical or financial capital for setting up campuses. While foreign universities will be allowed to charge any amount of tuition and other fees, how can they generate profits for repatriation when the Supreme Court does not allow the operation of "for-profit" educational institutions? Foreign direct investment in the education sector is unclear.

A flawed approach

In fact, foreign investment in higher education institutions has to be attractive in terms of profit-making for both the country of origin of universities and the private investors. The U.S. and most countries in Asia and Europe allow for the establishment and operation of ‘for-profit’ institutions, while institutions in India operate on the basis of a "not-for-profit" basis. Therefore, the government’s approach to inviting foreign institutions to India without profits is flawed.

Additionally, students, who spend huge amounts on their foreign degrees, are looking for decent earnings in multinational corporations, for which India’s employment market is ill-suited due to massive unemployment.

The proposed University Grants Commission guidelines are ill-conceived and populist.

UGC had earlier invited foreign universities, but none have responded thus far. Why? This must have been investigated to know why foreign higher education institutions are not interested in locating their campuses in India. The experiences of countries in West Asia, even with financial support, have not been successful as expected due to various regulatory, financial and academic reasons.

In the past, some of the best-performing universities in India have tried to establish collaborative arrangements with credible foreign institutions for students and teachers to exchange and promote joint research programs. Even though UGC supported such collaborations by Indian universities, the Ministries of Home and External Affairs have not encouraged students or faculty exchanges, citing national security concerns.

In view of this, the proposed University Grants Commission guidelines are ill-conceived and populist, and hardly take note of the educational and financial interests of foreign universities.

M.M. Ansari is a former member of the University Grants Commission and Mohammad Naushad Khan is sub-editor at Radiance Viewsweekly.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.


Feminists Infiltrate The “Incelosphere” — Where Toxic Content Warps Modern Masculinity

An increasing number of male teens and young adults who've experienced feelings of rejection wind up in what's been dubbed the “incelosphere,” a place where they can find mutual understanding in a world they think is against them. Two women Polish journalists spent two years on the online servers these “beta males” are flocking to in ever greater numbers.

Illustration of a man wearing a hoodie looking at a laptop, with two women watching over his shoulder.

Watching over "beta males" and their online toxic masculinity

AI-generated illustration / Worldcrunch
Patrycja Wieczorkiewicz

In her book For The Love Of Men: From Toxic To A More Mindful Masculinity, Canadian feminist writer Liz Plank explained that the struggle of women can never be one without confronting the crisis of manhood.

Plank is part of the forward-thinking feminist researchers and authors who've dedicated a significant amount of their work to the problems of men and masculinity, always sure to arouse suspicion. In reality, from a young age, we are forced into one of two oppressive patterns – masculinity and femininity – which in turn shape our behavior and our choices.

Keep reading...Show less

The latest