When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.


Political Intrusion, The Eternal Poison For Central Banks

European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi
European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi
Mark Gilbert

LONDON — In most of the developed world, central banks are free to set monetary policy without the interference of those who depend on voters for their employment. That independence, though, is "not set in stone," as former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan noted in his September 2007 memoirs. And there are worrying signs that, against the current backdrop of record-low interest rates, politicians are tempted to start meddling.

The latest attack on independence comes from a very unlikely source. In an article for the Telegraph newspaper published on Tuesday, former U.K. Foreign Secretary William Hague wrote that "central bankers have collectively lost the plot. They must raise interest rates or face their doom."

Bemoaning the lot of savers in a low-interest rate world has become commonplace. Prime Minister Theresa May was scathing earlier this month in her attack on the unwelcome side effects of Bank of England policy. German politicians have grilled European Central Bank President Mario Draghi about his negative interest-rate policies.

But this is different. Hague went on to issue a sinister threat to the Fed and its central-banking brethren: "Unless they change course soon, they will find their independence increasingly under attack. The only way out is for the U.S. Fed to summon the courage to lead the way to higher interest rates, and others to follow slowly but surely. If they fail to do so, the era of their much-vaunted independence will come, possibly quite dramatically, to its end."

Last month, U.S. presidential candidate Donald Trump accused Fed Chair Janet Yellen of keeping U.S. borrowing costs "artificially low to get Obama retired." Trump also said Yellen was "very political," and that "she should be ashamed of herself." In February, he tweeted that it is "important to audit the Federal Reserve."

Now, whatever you think of Trump, his claim that Fed policy is partisan and designed to aid the Democrat party is patently absurd, and easily dismissed as part of his scattergun approach to politics and populism. But Hague is no firebrand with a story to sell; he's an old-fashioned Tory patrician who was leader of the Conservative party at one point, and was a member of Parliament for a quarter-century.

So Hague's comments -- coming just a day after the prime minister had to publicly declare her support for Bank of England Governor Mark Carney -- seem like nothing less than a shot across the bows of central-bank independence. Toby Nangle, co-head of asset allocation at Columbia Threadneedle Asset Management, summarized the threat in a tweet: "Raise rates or have your independence revoked."

[rebelmouse-image 27090480 alt="""" original_size="1024x718" expand=1]

Bank of England chief Mark Carney, back in 2010 when he led Canada's central bank Photo — WEF

Carney has already made his displeasure known. "It can be difficult sometimes if there are political comments on our policies," he said last week. "The objectives are what are set by the politicians. The policies are done by technocrats. We are not going to take instruction on our policies from the political side."

Central bank independence isn't enshrined in the laws that govern the universe; the Bank of England, for example, has been free to set interest rates as it sees fit for less than two decades. And while worries that independence is under attack might seem overblown, re-reading what May told her party last month in the light of Hague's article this week should give pause: "While monetary policy, with super-low interest rates and quantitative easing provided the necessary emergency medicine after the financial crash, we have to acknowledge there have been some bad side effects. People with assets got richer, people without them have suffered, people with mortgages have found their debt cheaper, people with savings have found themselves poorer. A change has got to come and we are going to deliver it."

Governments have abdicated responsibility for economic stability to their central banks. They've set inflation targets of 2 percent almost everywhere. Politicians can't complain if their appointees attempt to fulfill their mandates by keeping interest rates at record lows -- even when that hurts savers.

But the more powerful central bankers become, the more tempted politicians will be to meddle. Here's what Alan M. Taylor, an economics professor at the University of California in Davis, told a conference organized by the Austrian central bank in Vienna last month:

"Society may now be asking more of central banks, and central banks will now try to find a way to serve those goals. Central banks can therefore expect to become less independent and more politicized going forward."

I'm as skeptical as any gold bug of the merits of allowing unelected academic economists to run the global economy; but my concerns are about the resulting groupthink and the lack of entrepreneurs and business folk among the policy makers, not their freedom. But trying to bully central bankers into raising interest rates by threatening to annul their independence seems like a dangerous game -- especially given the fragility of the global economy.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.


My Wife, My Boyfriend — And Grandkids: A Careful Coming Out For China's Gay Seniors

A series of interviews in Wuhan with aging gay men — all currently or formerly married to women — reveals a hidden story of how Chinese LGBTQ culture is gradually emerging from the shadows.

Image of two senior men playing chinese Checkers.

A friendly game of Checkers in Dongcheng, Beijing, China.

Wang Er

WUHAN — " What do you think of that guy sitting there, across from us? He's good looking."

" Then you should go and talk to him."

“ Too bad that I am old..."

Grandpa Shen was born in 1933. He says that for the past 40 years, he's been "repackaged," a Chinese expression for having come out as gay. Before his wife died when he was 50, Grandpa Shen says he was was a "standard" straight Chinese man. After serving in the army, he began working in a factory, and dated many women and evenutually got married.

"Becoming gay is nothing special, I found it very natural." Grandpa Shen says he discovered his homosexuality at the Martyrs' Square in Wuhan, a well-known gay men's gathering place.

✉️ You can receive our LGBTQ+ International roundup every week directly in your inbox. Subscribe here.

Wuhan used to have different such ways for LGBTQ+ to meet: newspaper columns, riversides, public toilets, bridges and baths to name but a few. With urbanization, many of these locations have disappeared. The transformation of Martyrs' Square into a park has gradually become a place frequented by middle-aged and older gay people in Wuhan, where they play cards and chat and make friends. There are also "comrades" (Chinese slang for gay) from outside the city who come to visit.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest