When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Geopolitics

Was A French Military Chaplain In Afghanistan A Raging Islamophobe?

Upon returning from Afghanistan, French Army Chaplain Julien de Pommerol accused the military of bending to Islamic pressures and "babouche-licking." Some accuse him of Islamophobia, others applaud his candor.

French forces and Afghan National Army soldiers inaugurate a new bridge in Kapisa (isafmedia)
French forces and Afghan National Army soldiers inaugurate a new bridge in Kapisa (isafmedia)
Nathalie Guibert and Stéphanie Le Bars

Every year, the chief of the French army addresses the young officers graduating from the prestigious Saint-Cyr military academy. But this year, there was a break with tradition. General Elrick Irastroza did not just give the standard talk on rules of command: he reminded his audience of Article 1 of the Constitution, which establishes France's prized secularism, or "laïcité", and freedom of belief.

His comments on the Constitution were hardly a casual choice. He was making reference to the poisonous issue of Benoit Julien de Pommerol, a controversial military chaplain stationed last year in Afghanistan.

Last summer, after a tour of duty in Afghanistan, Pommerol wrote an end-of-mission report denouncing the French army's "deference" to and "almost servile fear" of Islam. He went on to accuse the army of "babouche-licking." Less than a year later, the chaplain is adamant: "It's not charitable to keep scandals under wraps."

In his report, Julien cites several examples of what he sees as deviances: female soldiers wearing the veil, building mosques "with French taxpayers' money," and preparing an end-of-Ramadan feast for Afghans.

Strikes chord with some soldiers

The "Pommerol report" should have remained a secret. Instead, it was published on the Internet, sparking extreme reactions among growing tensions towards Islam in France. Many Catholic soldiers rejected the report. For others, however, the chaplain's words seem to have struck a cord.

"I don't think we can speak of Islamophobia, but if this report was exploited, that means it fits with national sensitivities that can be referred to as anti-Islamic," admits Luc Ravel, a military bishop. He believes the chaplain's report to be "troubling in form," "violent, excessive and obsessive." But he refuses to judge its meaning, and questions the nature of the reported facts. "Were these misinterpreted acts of respect or orders of submission?"

"There are no other instructions to be given other than the texts that guarantee secularism," said the chief of the French armed forces. "Then it's a matter courtesy, common sense and education to respect other people's religion." The army admitted a "mistake," regarding the order given to a female soldier to cover her head, but denied Pommerol's other accusations.

French Foreign Minister Gerard Longuet called the report "exaggerated or vague," saying the French army has been trying to "earn acceptance by respecting local customs." That a soldier was asked to cover her head was "in no way a general rule of behavior (…) but a specific decision made in a specific operational context." The context, in this case, was a joint mission with the Afghan army.

In September, Julien will become the military chaplain in the French Antilles. "This is not a punishment," according to Longuet's entourage.

Photo credit - Isafmedia

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Geopolitics

Modi Is Wrong: Russia's War Also Creates Real Risks For India

By shrugging aside Russia’s aggression, India has shown indifference to fears that China could follow Russia’s example.

Photo of India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Russian President Vladimir Putin

India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi Visits Russia

Anita Inder Singh*

-OpEd-

NEW DELHI — India is wrong to dismiss Russia’s war in Ukraine as Europe’s problem. The illegality and destructiveness of the invasion, and consequential food and energy crises, have global ramifications.

Stay up-to-date with the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war, with our exclusive international coverage.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter.

This explains why 143 out of the 193 member-states of the UN General Assembly voted against recognizing Russia’s illegal annexation of four Ukrainian regions after holding sham referenda there. Ninety-three voted in favor of expelling Russia from the UN Human Rights Council.

India has abstained from every vote in the UN condemning Russia’s aggression in Ukraine. The reason? Moscow is India’s top arms supplier and some 70% of India’s military platforms are of Russian origin.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest