When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.


The Streets Of Paris: Who To Target, The Prostitute Or Pimp?

Prostitution is on the rise in Paris. The number of streetwalkers on the outer northern boulevards of the city has increased, as authorities debate so-called "passive solicitation," and look for new ways to crack down on the sex trade.

Paris' Pigalle Red Light District
Paris' Pigalle Red Light District
Anne Chemin

PARIS - They're sitting on a bench along one of the boulevards of northern Paris. Over-the-knee white boots, fur-collared coats, mini skirts: despite the cold, all three are waiting for a car to stop by the sidewalk. They chat while smoking cigarettes, taking advantage of a momentary lull in the traffic to relax, rolling their eyes when truck drivers honk at them. Gym regulars walk by in their sweatpants, people go shopping and a man looks at them and sighs: "They're already out on the prowl…"

It's 8pm, this March evening, and the first prostitutes have already taken their places on Boulevard Ney, in the 18th arrondissement in Northwest Paris. Here as elsewhere, street prostitution has increased so much in the past months that local Socialist party politicians called on the Paris City Council last December to reinforce initiatives aimed at helping woman caught up in prostitution, and to increase efforts to stamp out "pimping and the sexual exhibition it triggers on the street."

In the 18th arrondissement, the Boulevards of the Marshals, a network of thoroughfares encircling the outskirts of the city, have been taken over by Eastern European prostitution gangs. "These are highly organized systems with up to 50 girls," says Jean-Philippe Lenormand, a senior police official of Paris' vice squad. "They are operated by one or two people who regularly travel back and forth from the Balkans, but there are also people smugglers, "cabbies' to drive the girls to the streets and minders who keep an eye on the network's patch. In these networks, there's a lot of violence, constraints, and threats on the prostitutes and their families who stayed back home."

In the neighborhoods of Chateau Rouge or Barbes in the 18th arrondissement as well as around Rue Saint-Denis in the 2nd arrondissement, newly arrived prostitutes tend to come from English-speaking Africa – Ghana, Nigeria and Sierra Leone. "These are smaller operations," says Lenormand. "Each Mama – a former prostitute – controls four or five girls, manages the turf, finds rooms and gets a big cut of the earnings." According to Lenormand, the Paris region – especially the Bois de Vincennes, the Bois de Boulogne, the Rue Saint-Denis and the 18th arrondissement – has 600 to 800 streetwalkers, 80 percent of whom are foreigners.

If prostitution is rife it is because it is a very lucrative activity: "The profits are easy and very big," says Lenormand. He says a Paris prostitute who sees roughly a dozen clients a day can generate about 10,000 euros ($14,000) a month for her network. When there are dozens of girls working, income for the network can skyrocket. These gains are split between the leaders, the "cabbies', the minders and to a lesser extent the girls: it usually takes them more than a year to pay back their smugglers.

In 2003, when he was the French Interior Minister, Nicolas Sarkozy introduced a new law aimed at stamping out street prostitution by going after the so-called "passive soliciting" where streetwalkers mingle with potential clients without actively advertising their trade. "Why is a young Albanian girl put on the Paris streets by pimps? Because these modern-day slave-drivers don't risk anything (…) By making passive soliciting an offense, we get these poor girls out of the networks that exploit them." Sarkozy hoped to deal these networks a final blow by making it easier to arrest prostitutes: passive soliciting could lead up to two months in jail and a 3,750 euro ($5,300) fine.

But eight years on, street prostitution has actually increased. "This law was disastrous," says France Arnould, director of Friends of the women's bus, an association which gives prostitutes access to health care and legal aid. "There are more prostitutes than ever before. Many are hiding in the woods, under bridges, in places where they are very isolated which makes them very vulnerable. Some police officers have even gone so far as to confiscate condoms as proof of passive soliciting. Try and teach them about HIV after that!" Myriam El-Khomri, deputy mayor of Paris in charge of security sums up the situation: "We punish the prostitutes, not the pimps."

On the justice system front, making soliciting a crime has been equally ineffective. Over the years, the number of cases has plummeted: in 2006, there were 529 convictions in France, 459 in 2007, 336 in 2008 and 226 in 2009. Not because prostitution has declined but because magistrates overwhelmingly direct these procedures to towards alternatives other than prosecution.

If the offender rarely makes it in front of a court, it's simply because it is hard to characterize: how do you define an attitude – passive soliciting – that doesn't imply any "positive" action? "According to the Cour de Cassation (France's court of last resort), a person's clothes – cleavage, mini skirt – or the fact of bending over to a driver or staying for hours at a red light cannot justify being arrested for passive soliciting," explains Naima Rudloff, deputy prosecutor and director of the real-time treatment and crimes department for the Paris prosecution.

For many policemen and magistrates, Sarkozy's tough speeches against prostitution have not amounted to much other than covering up the difficulties of a more complex battle: the fight against pimping. In 20 years, prostitution has globalised: networks have no borders, recruiting in the Balkans as well as in Africa, and taking over European sidewalks. "They're hard to dismantle: prostitutes rarely betray their pimps," says Lenormand. "They're continually threatened and they know that that after a certain amount of time they can hope to take control of new recruits. In the end, everyone is on the act."

Read the original article in French

Photo - Dionetian

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

FOCUS: Russia-Ukraine War

That Man In Mariupol: Is Putin Using A Body Double To Avoid Public Appearances?

Putin really is meeting with Xi in Moscow — we know that. But there are credible experts saying that the person who showed up in Mariupol the day before was someone else — the latest report that the Russian president uses a doppelganger for meetings and appearances.

screen grab of Putin in a dark down jacket

During the visit to Mariupol, the Presidential office only released screen grabs of a video

Russian President Press Office/TASS via ZUMA
Anna Akage

Have no doubt, the Vladimir Putin we’re seeing alongside Xi Jinping this week is the real Vladimir Putin. But it’s a question that is being asked after a range of credible experts have accused the Russian president of sending a body double for a high-profile visit this past weekend in the occupied Ukrainian city of Mariupol.

Stay up-to-date with the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war, with our exclusive international coverage.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter.

Reports and conspiracy theories have circulated in the past about the Russian leader using a stand-in because of health or security issues. But the reaction to the Kremlin leader's trip to Mariupol is the first time that multiple credible sources — including those who’ve spent time with him in the past — have cast doubt on the identity of the man who showed up in the southeastern Ukrainian city that Russia took over last spring after a months-long siege.

Russian opposition politician Gennady Gudkov is among those who confidently claim that a Putin look-alike, or rather one of his look-alikes, was in the Ukrainian city.

"Now that there is a war going on, I don't rule out the possibility that someone strongly resembling or disguised as Putin is playing his role," Gudkov said.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest