When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

CAIXINMEDIA

Son, Wife Or Foreign Friend: Favorite False Alibis For Chinese Damage Control

Rolls-Royce dealership, Hangzhou, China
Rolls-Royce dealership, Hangzhou, China
Zhang Fan

Putting the right spin on your words is a science. Obviously, the civil servants who owe a fiduciary duty to the public have an urgent need to master this subject. And it helps to shift the blame on someone else, a child, a spouse, or a convenient foreigner will do.

Two weeks ago Yang Dacai, head of the Occupational Safety Department of Shaanxi Province, became notorious across China because of his inappropriate smile when he visited the scene of disastrous transport accident.

He said that it was an “accidental expression.” Chinese netizens dissatisfied with this explanation did some research and found out that Yang owned five different luxury brand watches. Even as Yang was insisting that they had all been bought with his own income, even more watches continue to be discovered, each one more expensive than the last.

He responded that his yearly wage alone is around 170-180,000 RMB ($27,000-$28,000). When pushed further to explain, Yang came up with: “My son also adores watches. We occasionally share the same ones."

Ten days ago Fang Daguo, a political commissar of Guangzhou City’s Armed Forces Department, beat up an air hostess from China Southern Airlines. This triggered another huge denunciation online. Fang then claimed, through the propaganda department of the district he works for, that it was his wife who had had a conflict with the flight attendant, he himself did not participate in the incident.

Then came the exposure of the Hefei Children’s Welfare Institute, which spent a huge sum of money buying a Mercedes-Benz just to keep it idle in the garage. The director of the Institute justified his action: “The car is mainly used when there are foreign guests who came to Hefei to adopt a child.”

Three trump cards

Son, wife, and foreign guest: these three trump cards, however, did not silence or send away the public. On the contrary, it inspired the media as well the netizens to even more relentless pursuits of truth. An African student even exposed the lies of Fang Daguo. He had been a witness travelling in the same plane as the political commissar.

What is intriguing is the reason that each time some incident occurs, officials are always in a hurry to turn around their words, or even brazenly lie.

It’s because of China’s lack of system to publish officials’ assets that Yang Dacai can use his son as a justification. It’s because official institutes don’t have a transparent financial system that a charitable institute dares to blame their responsibility onto foreigners. And it is because bureaucrats shield one another and authorities always hasten to cover up scandals and maintain stability that Fang Daguo did not hesitate to proclaim a falsehood.

The consequence is that the public immediately sees the irrational excuses, full of obvious holes, of the concerned parties. Those in the spotlight and the public enter into a battle of wits, before the truth is gradually squeezed into oblivion. Instead, there should be immediate, clear, logical and vigorous investigation, and mechanisms for accountability.

Therefore in the face of a crisis, civil servants dare to say anything that strikes their fancy, because they believe the pressure is but temporary. All they need to do is find an excuse. Once the incident calms down, the accountability mechanism, questioning the flaws in their words, will simply vanish.

However, what the public and the society need most is clarification, not excuses or lies. Who then ought to question the truth and stop these absurd public spectacles? Until someone steps in, all these events deplete the government’s credibility and damage the existing foundations of society.

  

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Geopolitics

For Erdogan, Blocking Sweden's NATO Bid Is Perfect For His Reelection Campaign

Turkey's objections to Swedish membership of NATO may mean that Finland joins first. And as he approaches an election at home, Turkish President Erdogan is playing the game to his advantage.

For Erdogan, Blocking Sweden's NATO Bid Is Perfect For His Reelection Campaign

January 11, 2023, Ankara (Turkey): Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan at the International Conference of the Board of Grievances on January 11.

Turkish Presidency / APA Images via ZUMA Press Wire
Pierre Haski

-Analysis-

PARIS — This story has all the key elements of our age: the backdrop of the war in Ukraine, the excessive ambitions of an autocrat, the opportunism of a right-wing demagogue, Islamophobia... And at the end, a country, Sweden, whose NATO membership, which should have been only a formality, has been blocked.

Last spring, under the shock of the invasion of Ukraine by Vladimir Putin's Russia, Sweden and Finland, two neutral countries in northern Europe, decided to apply for membership in NATO. For Sweden, this is a major turning point: the kingdom’s neutrality had lasted more than 150 years.

Turkey's President Erdogan raised objections. It demanded that Sweden stop sheltering Kurdish opponents in its country. This has nothing to do with NATO or Ukraine, but everything to do with Erdogan's electoral agenda, as he campaigns for the Turkish presidential elections next May.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest