When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Enjoy unlimited access to quality journalism.

Limited time offer

Get your 30-day free trial!
Nazarbayev looms large in Kazakhstan
Nazarbayev looms large in Kazakhstan
Elena Chernenko

ASTANA - Earlier this month, Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev rolled out his new project for cooperation between the East and West -- and it lacked neither ambition nor a healthy supply of alphabet-soup acronyms .

A person close to President Nazarbayev’s administration said this was the most audacious of Kazakhstan’s recent foreign policy projects, unveiled at at a meeting of foreign ministers of member countries of the Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia (CICA), an international group led by Kazakhstan.

The new organization is envisioned as a way to bring together representatives of the United Nations, the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), CICA, NATO, the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), the European Union, and the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS). In other words, all organizations of the Eurasian continent, from the Atlantic to the Pacific, that deal with security questions.

The Kazakh government has been considering this project since 2010, but officially enscribed the project only this past August.

“In spite of their diversity, the organizations in the European and Eurasian regions take little advantage of opportunities to work together. Our idea is to fill that gap,” the source explained. “We are not talking about creating another major organization with a big secretariat.”

The authors of this new project say it is possible that it would grow into a new organization in the future, but for now they are just encouraging members to communicate more “in the field.” Kazakhstan envisions special summits, and has promised to release a calendar of potential meetings before the end of the year.

When asked how this new initiative would benefit Astana, the source close to the Kazakh government said, “It is important for Kazakhstan to have an influence in the processes that are taking place in diverse areas, without trying to take on a role of world dominance. In addition, the project will allow us to improve the country’s international image.”

Doomed to fail?

In Russia, the reaction to Kazakhstan’s new initiative was guarded. “We welcome any suggestion aimed at increasing cooperation among international organizations,” a Russian diplomatic source said. “But based on our past experiences in trying to create partnerships, I can tell you that it is not an easy task.”

The diplomat said that CSTO, a military alliance between several former Soviet states, has tried on several occasions to work with NATO on problems such as the drug trade in Afghanistan. But NATO has never been interested.

According to some experts, the Kazakh initiative is doomed to the same fate. “From a logical point of view, the idea is both necessary and modern, but it is unlikely that the initiative can be carried out. For a number of reasons, initiatives like this one never find support in the West,” said Vadim Kosyulin, a senior researcher at the Russian Center for Political Studies. Koslyulin said that in Europe and the United States, CSTO and SCO are seen as nothing more than ways to counteract the western presence in Central Asia.

“In addition, the West is convinced that CSTO and SCO belong to undemocratic regimes. And on the whole, it is more convenient for NATO to work with other countries on a bilateral basis than with a bloc,” Koslyulin said, adding, “The most important thing for the Kazakh idea to work is missing -- trust. And that lack of trust is on all sides.”

A source at NATO confirmed Koslyulin’s analysis. “We heard more about these major projects in the 1990s, when everyone wanted to cook up some kind of grand institutional soup,” the source at NATO said. “Now isn’t the time for grandiose ideas. We have to solve our current problems in a timely manner.”

The source at NATO added that Astana’s suggestion was “not bad,” but “not realistic.”

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Coronavirus

Chinese Students' "Absurd" Protest Against COVID Lockdowns: Public Crawling

While street demonstrations have spread in China to protest the strict Zero-COVID regulations, some Chinese university students have taken up public acts of crawling to show what extended harsh lockdowns are doing to their mental state.

​Screenshot of a video showing Chinese students crawling on a soccer pitch

Screenshot of a video showing Chinese students crawling

Shuyue Chen

Since last Friday, the world has watched a wave of street protests have taken place across China as frustration against extended lockdowns reached a boiling point. But even before protesters took to the streets, Chinese university students had begun a public demonstration that challenges and shames the state's zero-COVID rules in a different way: public displays of crawling, as a kind of absurdist expression of their repressed anger under three years of strict pandemic control.

Xin’s heart was beating fast as her knees reached the ground. It was her first time joining the strange scene at the university sports field, so she put on her hat and face mask to cover her identity.

Kneeling down, with her forearms supporting her body from the ground, Xin started crawling with three other girls as a group, within a larger demonstration of other small groups. As they crawled on, she felt the sense of fear and embarrassment start to disappear. It was replaced by a liberating sense of joy, which had been absent in her life as a university student in lockdown for so long.

Yes, crawling in public has become a popular activity among Chinese university students recently. There have been posters and videos of "volunteer crawling" across universities in China. At first, it was for the sake of "fun." Xin, like many who participated, thought it was a "cult-like ritual" in the beginning, but she changed her mind. "You don't care about anything when crawling, not thinking about the reason why, what the consequences are. You just enjoy it."

The reality out there for Chinese university students has been grim. For Xin, her university started daily COVID-19 testing in November, and deliveries, including food, are banned. Apart from the school gate, all exits have been padlock sealed.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest