When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Already a subscriber? Log in .

You've reached your limit of one free article.

Get unlimited access to Worldcrunch

You can cancel anytime .


Exclusive International news coverage

Ad-free experience NEW

Weekly digital Magazine NEW

9 daily & weekly Newsletters

Access to Worldcrunch archives

Free trial

30-days free access, then $2.90
per month.

Annual Access BEST VALUE

$19.90 per year, save $14.90 compared to monthly billing.save $14.90.

Subscribe to Worldcrunch

Bulgaria And Hungary: Risks Of A Pro-Russian Alliance Inside The EU

Bulgaria had sworn off Russian gas imports, but then its government collapsed. Now pro-Russian politicians are in power, which for the European Union means there is much more at stake than just energy supply.

Sofia, Bulgaria

Bulgarians are split between pro-Western and pro-Russian politics.

Philip Volkmann-Schluck

The letter Z, a symbol of support for Putin’s war in Ukraine, has appeared on Bulgarian government buildings in Sofia. Last week, demonstrators fixed a Z in black tape to the entrance of the Ministry of Energy’s headquarters.

Stay up-to-date with the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war, with our exclusive international coverage.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter.

They were protesting their government’s announcement that it would reopen negotiations with Russia about importing gas – although Bulgaria had declared public support for Kyiv and subsequently stopped all Russian imports. “Putin’s gas is a trap,” one of the placards reads.

These scenes have been growing more common in the Bulgarian capital since the reformist government led by Prime Minister Kiril Petkov was ousted last month in a no-confidence vote. Petkov had pledged to tackle corruption and taken a strong stance against Russia's invasion. But his coalition government fell after just seven months in office when an ally quit.

The country is currently being run by an interim government under pro-Russian President Rumen Radev.

Under the Kremlin's influence

But the protesters’ concerns go far beyond the accusation that their country will be supporting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine if it resumes buying gas from the Russian state-owned energy corporation Gazprom. Acting Minister of Energy Rosen Hristov recently said this was “unavoidable” and that otherwise the country would not survive the winter.

In sticking the letter Z to the wall of the Ministry of Energy, the protesters are accusing their government of being under the Kremlin’s direct influence. Politicians from the ousted government agree, and with good reason. Petkov’s government, which was in power from December until August, pledged to fight against the widespread corruption in Bulgaria. It offered the public proof that high-ranking politicians and their colleagues had been receiving Russian money for years, which influenced their decisions to make the country dependent on Russian gas.

Bulgaria is struggling to choose its path: democracy or cronyism, pro-Western or pro-Russian

The claims led to Russian diplomats being kicked out of the country on suspicion of espionage. Moscow was clearly enraged. In April, Bulgaria was – alongside Poland – the first EU country to have Russia turn off the gas supply completely.

In response, Petkov’s government ordered tankers of liquid gas from the United States and sped up work on a pipeline intended to transport gas from Azerbaijan to Bulgaria and the rest of Europe. But then the precarious five-party coalition, led by Petkov’s party We Continue the Change, broke down.The fight against corruption and cronyism among politicians, the mafia and dodgy businesses had garnered too many opponents.

Olaf Scholz and Kiril Petkov

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz is welcomed by Bulgarian Prime Minister Kiril Petkov in Sofia on June 11, 2022.

Michael Kappeler/dpa/ZUMA

Public opinion split

In early October, Bulgaria will once again hold elections, for the fourth time in less than two years. The country is struggling to choose its path: democracy or cronyism, pro-Western or pro-Russian. For the EU, there is a lot at stake. Bulgaria could play a key role in Europe’s energy supply – if its government is wiling. And another potential headache for Brussels is the possibility that Bulgaria could follow Hungary’s example in opposing strict sanctions on Russia.

However, unlike in Hungary, where Prime Minister Viktor Orbán won re-election with his pro-Putin policies, public opinion in Bulgaria is split. That means campaigning politicians need to approach the Russia question carefully. Bulgaria traditionally has strong cultural ties to Russia, and the Kremlin has aggressively targeted the country with propaganda.

At the same time, citizens have been protesting against the cronyism that has held it back and made it the smallest economy in the EU. Tihomir Bezlov, a Senior Analyst at the Center for the Study of Democracy in Sofia, has been monitoring public opinion and Russian influence in Bulgaria for years. He says that although Putin’s invasion of Ukraine has met with “severe disapproval” among Bulgarian people, studies show that pro- and anti-Russian sentiment are “almost equally” represented within Bulgarian society.

That is surely why President Radev and the acting ministers chosen by him have held back from making explicitly pro-Russian statements. Bulgaria is still quietly sending Soviet-era munitions to Ukraine via Poland. However, analyst Bezlov assumes that the current cabinet has “lines of communication” to Moscow that are “not public.”

Ousted Prime Minister Petkov is standing for re-election. The 42-year-old businessman studied at Harvard and went into politics to fight corruption. On his campaign tour, his main focus is not geopolitics. Instead he is concentrating on his party’s core priorities: democracy, jobs and how the economic situation affects everyday citizen — although that has a lot to do with independent energy supply.

Breaking Moscow's pipeline monopoly

In a phone call, Petkov outlines how from his first day in office, his government prioritized work on finishing a pipeline that would connect Bulgaria to the Trans Adriatic Pipeline, which transports gas from Azerbaijan across Turkey to Greece and Italy. From 2023, the plan is for this pipeline to supply other countries in southern Europe with liquid gas from Greece, which experts say would break Russia’s monopoly in the region.

According to Petkov, the previous Bulgarian government “delayed the pipeline for years and constantly came up with new excuses for why it wasn’t finished.” But he says it could be operational already: “It has been completed and tested.” However, Minister of Energy Hristov claims that it is not yet functional and that agreements with Azerbaijan are unexpectedly having to be renegotiated.The ships bringing liquid gas ordered from the U.S. are suddenly being reconsidered as well.

What if the next government allows Bulgaria to be under the thumb of Gazprom once more.

Work progressed much more quickly on the far shorter Balkan Stream pipeline, which transports Russian gas to Hungary and Serbia: it took three years to build and became operational in 2021. “Bulgaria doesn’t get a single molecule of gas from this pipeline. It only serves to bypass Ukraine,” says Petkov. He estimates the project received €1.5 billion of public funds.

When his party started tidying up the government buildings in Sofia early this year, Petkov says they found a brand new SUV in the garage of an advisor to his predecessor, Prime Minister Boyko Borissov, paid for by the Russian company that operates the pipeline. “That is the most expensive car in all of Bulgaria. It cost our taxpayers €1.5 billion for this useless pipeline.”

Mural of Putin in

A mural depicting Vladimir Putin in Sofia, Bulgaria.

Matias Basualdo/ZUMA

An alliance between Sofia and Budapest

According to polls, Petkov’s reformist party is neck and neck with Borissov’s GERB party. But each side has only around a quarter of the votes. The rest are split across the political spectrum, among small reformist parties, socialists and openly anti-Western alliances.

“It would have huge consequences for Europe if the next government destroys everything Petkov has worked for and allows Bulgaria to be under the thumb of Gazprom once more,” says Bulgaria expert Jakub Bielamowicz, an analyst at the Institute of New Europe. He suspects the reformist government would have had an easier task if the war in Ukraine hadn’t caused such a stark polarization of opinion in Bulgaria.

Now the EU is facing the prospect of a possible alliance between Sofia and Budapest that could block sanctions against Moscow. “It is unlikely that Bulgaria would be as openly pro-Russian as Hungary currently is,” says Bielamowicz. “But the government in Sofia could certainly find ways to delay or obstruct measures.”

And that is precisely what the EU and Ukraine don’t need.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

FOCUS: Israel-Palestine War

Bibi Blinked: How The Ceasefire Deal Could Flip Israel's Whole Gaza War Logic

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has pushed ahead a deal negotiated via Qatar, for a four-day truce and an exchange of 50 hostages for 150 Palestinian prisoners. Though the humanitarian and political pressure was mounting, Israel's all-out assault is suddenly halted, with unforeseen consequences for the future.

photo of someone holding a poster of a hostage

Families of Israeli hostages rally in Jerusalem

Nir Alon/ZUMA
Pierre Haski

Updated Nov. 22, 2023 at 8:55 p.m.


PARIS — It's the first piece of good news in 46 days of war. In the early hours of Wednesday, Israel agreed to a deal that included a four-day ceasefire and the release of some of the hostages held by Hamas — 30 children and 20 women — in exchange for 150 Palestinian prisoners, again women and children. The real question is what happens next.

For the latest news & views from every corner of the world, Worldcrunch Today is the only truly international newsletter. Sign up here.

But first, this agreement, negotiated through the intermediary of Qatar, whose role is essential in this phase, must be implemented right away. This is a complex negotiation, because unlike the previous hostage-for-prisoner exchanges, it is taking place in the midst of a major war.

On the Palestinian side, although Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh is present in Doha, he does not make the decision alone — he must have the agreement of the leaders of the military wing, who are hiding somewhere in Gaza. It takes 24 hours to send a message back and forth. As you can imagine, it's not as simple as a phone call.

And on the Israeli side, a consensus had to be built around the agreement. Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right allies were opposed to the deal — in line with their eradication logic — even at the cost of Israeli lives. But the opposition of these discredited parties was ignored, and that will leave its mark.

Keep reading...Show less

The latest