When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

India

The Families Left Behind After India's Botched Sterilizations

Womens Groups Protest in New Delhi against sterilization camps.
Womens Groups Protest in New Delhi against sterilization camps.
Bismillah Geelani

NEW DELHI — Archana, who is just 15, is desperately trying to put her 3-month-old brother to sleep. He's crying out for his mother, who died last week after going to a government-run sterilization camp.

At least 15 others suffered the same fate, and scores of others are seriously ill after undergoing tubectomies at two Indian sterilization "camps."

Ongoing investigations point to contaminated drugs given to the women as a possible cause of death. But a dirty operating room and surgeries performed in a matter of minutes with unsanitized instruments have raised serious questions about India's approach to population control and public health care.

As the eldest child in her family, Archana is now charged with taking care of her three siblings, as her father is disabled.

"I miss my mother a lot," she says. "My brothers and sisters are waiting for her. They think she has gone somewhere. They refuse to eat, but I somehow manage to make them have something. I'm particularly worried about the youngest one. He doesn't take the bottle and keeps crying all day and night."

Archana's mother didn't want to get pregnant again. So when she heard the government had set up a free sterilization camp in the area, she went. Soon after the surgery, she complained of severe abdominal pain and vomiting. She was rushed to a hospital, where she later died.

Fifteen other women who had the same operation suffered the same fate. They were all in their early thirties and leave behind breastfeeding babies. The deaths sparked massive protests in several cities. Under pressure, the local government says they are investigating several officials.

"We now have the report that confirms that the drugs were not up to standard and had poisonous elements," says Amar Agarwal, health minister for the Chhattisgarh state government in central India, where the botched sterilizations took place. "We have given the report to the police. They will thoroughly investigate it, and the culprits will be severely punished."

Another form of female oppression

The doctors performing the surgeries have also been arrested. They say they were under pressure to achieve a target number of surgeries set by the local government — performing up to 80 operations in just six hours in the town of Bilaspur.


Victims of botched sterilizations at Bilaspur's CIMS hospital — Photo: Ritesh Shukla/Pacific Press/ZUMA

Punit Bedi, a New Delhi gynecologist, says that was highly irresponsible. "The time needed just to wash hands between two procedures is three to five minutes," Bedi says. "Then you have to change and sterilize the equipment, and that takes a minimum of two hours, so obviously they used contaminated equipment for multiple surgeries, which is completely wrong and unacceptable medically, legally and ethically."

Nearly five million people are sterilized in India every year, more than 70% of them women, says Deepa Sinha, who works on health issues for the New Delhi-based research and advocacy institution Centre for Equity Studies.

"Among the various methods of contraception, female sterilization is the one with the most side effects and involves many risks, and yet this remains our main focus," Sinha says. "We are just obsessed with this. It has become another way of systemic oppression of women. The government campaign plays on existing gender inequality in the society and stresses female sterilization as if there is no other choice."

She says in many cases operations are performed without the full consent of the women, who are pushed to do it through incentives.

"So the couples will be told that if you sterilize after two children you will get this much money and such and such other benefits," Sinha says. "But if you don't, then you will be deprived of such and such development scheme running in your area and you won't be able to stand for a local body election, etc. This is internationally known to be a flawed approach."

The government rejects that point of view and says the sterilization program is completely voluntary. But the deaths in Chhattisgarh have lead to calls for the government to abandon the program.

Pradeep Pandey's daughter is one of the women who died after being sterilized, and he was the one who encouraged her to have the operation.

"I thought she had a complete family and now it was time to focus on their education and upbringing," he says. "I thought she would have a happy life with a small family, but I didn't know I was actually pushing her to death."

The local government has announced that he and each of the grieving families will receive just $700 in compensation. Pandey says his concern is about seeing those responsible brought to justice.

"The government must immediately punish the doctors involved and the manufacturers of the drugs," he says. "They should lose their jobs and be punished so that tragedies like this never ever happen again."

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Geopolitics

With The Chechen War Veterans Fighting For Ukraine — And For Revenge

They came to fight Russia, and to avenge the deaths of their loved ones and friends killed in Chechnya. Not wanting to sit in the trenches, they've found work in intelligence and sabotage.

Photo of members of the pro-Ukrainian Chechen group "Dzhokhar Dudayev Battalion" posing with weapons

Members of the pro-Ukrainian Chechen group "Dzhokhar Dudayev Battalion"

Lydia Mikhalchenko

At least five Chechen units are fighting for Ukraine, with more than 1,000 troops in each unit — and their number is growing.

Most of these Chechen fighters took part in the first and second Chechen wars with Russia, and were forced to flee to Ukraine or elsewhere in Europe after their defeat. Vazhnyye Istorii correspondent Lydia Mikhalchenko met with some of these fighters.

Four of the five Chechen battalions are part of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, and are paid the standard wages (about €4,000 per month for those on the front line) and receive equipment and supplies.

Chechen fighters say they appreciate that Ukrainian commanders don't order them to take unnecessary risks and attack objectives just to line up with an unrealistic schedule or important dates — something Russian generals are fond of doing.

Stay up-to-date with the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war, with our exclusive international coverage.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter.

The experienced Chechen fighters have taken fewer losses than many other units. Unhappy sitting in trenches, they mostly engage in reconnaissance and sabotage, moving along the front lines. "The Russians wake up, and the commander is gone. Or he's dead," one of the fighters explains.

Some of the fighters say that the Ukrainian war is easier than their previous battles in Chechnya, when they had to sit in the mountains for weeks without supplies and make do with small stocks of arms and ammunition. Some call this a "five-star war."

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest