When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.


China's Power Gap

Essay: Why do powerful officials break the rules and earn promotions, while a migrant mother faces bureaucratic traps that don't allow her child to go to school? Facing up to the question of administrative power is fundamental for China'

Planting a new future? (Snow Kisses Sky)
Planting a new future? (Snow Kisses Sky)
Zheng Ge*

The 18th century English essayist Oliver Goldsmith once wrote: "Laws grind the poor, and rich men rule the law." Put a slight twist on that sentence from "The Vicar of Wakefield," and you get a glimpse into the uglier side of Chinese society where "Laws grind the poor, and the powerful rule the law."

China is in fact a society centered around officials. Wealth is based on having power, whereas simply being rich doesn't necessarily bring power.

Two recent incidents clearly highlight two different ways in which laws have been implemented. One is a case of several officials who had lied on their resumes about their age and academic degrees. Far from being punished, one of them was even promoted. The other case is about an ordinary woman who bought a fake authenticating seal because she needed it to stamp a paper enabling her to register her child for school. Schooling is after all a basic right of the people and such seals are hawked on every street corner. Now she faces criminal prosecution.

The fraud perpetrated by the public servants undermines the government's credibility and legitimacy. They should therefore be severely punished. Meanwhile, a rural emigrant who faked a processing seal has disrupted the normal working order of an administrative department. But this administrative procedure is itself a burden on ordinary civil rights, and its legitimacy can be questioned. In short, the case should have been dealt with leniency.

As these examples show, the "selective enforcement of law" is clearly before us. The proclamation in the Chinese Constitution that "All men are equal before the law" is obviously challenged.

Righting wrongs

The government's household registration system discriminates against the school enrollment of migrant worker children. In the face of this institutional wrong, there is no recourse to non-legal means of circumventing the restriction.

Nevertheless, according to the Criminal Law and the Public Security Administration Punishment Law, "Forging, altering or selling and buying official state seals' is defined both as a crime and as a threat to public order. Yet it is obvious that her offense is minor and does not cause serious harm, and this behavior does not constitute a crime. At most it is to be defined as a violation of the rules, and be penalized as such.

Put aside the specific details, the two cases reveal wider issues.

Chinese traditional political philosophy emphasizes ethics flowing from the top, down. Officials must lead by example and establish a model as upright citizens themselves. The reason why China is poorly ruled is in large part attributed to the fact that Chinese officials do not respect the law, and they are indulgent with themselves while being strict with others.

The fake seal case happened because of the existence of some importunate red tape. There's no victim. Instead, the constitutionality and legitimacy of such regulatory means should be the subject at hand. The citizen's right to education is a basic constitutional right. The local People's Congress or local authority have no right to enact local regulations or policies that detract from people's basic rights enshrined in the constitution.

In administration and law enforcement, the public ought to be admitted to a larger and deeper scope of participation during the decision-making procedure. It has long been an issue that the majority of migrant workers, whose children are affected by the schooling regulations, have been excluded from any chance of participating in debating such an important policy.

The public is all too familiar with having to go back and forth to administration offices for a missing seal or letter. Chinese bureaucracy costs people too much time and energy: the "Convenient administration" slogan should be more than just a slogan.

Fake seals and fake papers have long existed semi-publicly in China. The public security should focus more on cleaning up this seller's market so the public doesn't act with the misconception that it's somehow normal to use fraud, and that the authorities will look the other way.

The integrity of civil servants must improve. Once found guilty of fraud, an official should never be employed as such again. Integrity is the basis of public authority as well as the foundation of the government's legitimacy. If an official is allowed to cheat and remain in the government, not only might he use his power to commit even more evil, but the phenomena itself can undermine the people's trust. Keeping a dishonest official is like not removing a tumor- the malignancy is bound to spread.

Privileges run rampant in China today, while law enforcement varies from person to person. Chinese people want change; and if the government does not respond and guide the change, it could end up facing a critical situation.

*Zheng Ge is Assistant Professor of Law at Hong Kong University

Read the original article in Chinese

Photo - Snow Kisses Sky

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.


In Northern Kenya, Where Climate Change Is Measured In Starving Children

The worst drought in 40 years, which has deepened from the effects of climate change, is hitting the young the hardest around the Horn of Africa. A close-up look at the victims, and attempts to save lives and limit lasting effects on an already fragile region in Kenya.

Photo of five mothers holding their malnourished children

At feeding time, nurses and aides encourage mothers to socialize their children and stimulate them to eat.

Georgina Gustin

KAKUMA — The words "Stabilization Ward" are painted in uneven black letters above the entrance, but everyone in this massive refugee camp in Kakuma, Kenya, calls it ya maziwa: The place of milk.

Rescue workers and doctors, mothers and fathers, have carried hundreds of starving children through the doors of this one-room hospital wing, which is sometimes so crowded that babies and toddlers have to share beds. A pediatric unit is only a few steps away, but malnourished children don’t go there. They need special care, and even that doesn’t always save them.

In an office of the International Rescue Committee nearby, Vincent Opinya sits behind a desk with figures on dry-erase boards and a map of the camp on the walls around him. “We’ve lost 45 children this year due to malnutrition,” he says, juggling emergencies, phone calls, and texts. “We’re seeing a significant increase in malnutrition cases as a result of the drought — the worst we’ve faced in 40 years.”

From January to June, the ward experienced an 800 percent rise in admissions of children under 5 who needed treatment for malnourishment — a surge that aid groups blame mostly on a climate change-fueled drought that has turned the region into a parched barren.

Opinya, the nutrition manager for the IRC here, has had to rattle off these statistics many times, but the reality of the numbers is starting to crack his professional armor. “It’s a very sad situation,” he says, wearily. And he believes it will only get worse. A third year of drought is likely on the way.

More children may die. But millions will survive malnutrition and hunger only to live through a compromised future, researchers say. The longer-term health effects of this drought — weakened immune systems, developmental problems — will persist for a generation or more, with consequences that will cascade into communities and societies for decades.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

The latest