When the world gets closer.

We help you see farther.

Sign up to our expressly international daily newsletter.

Enjoy unlimited access to quality journalism.

Limited time offer

Get your 30-day free trial!
InterNations -Your expat community
Economy

Why The Era Of Low-Cost Air Travel Must End

Many of us have become accustomed to cheap flights, but as prices spiral, it's time to ask about their true cost. And politicians' plan to bring in cheap labor to keep down prices is doomed to fail.

Ryanair

Passengers sit near Ryanair airplane

Thomas Straubhaar

-Analysis-

BERLIN — You get what you pay for. It’s a cliché, but it’s true. It is hypocritical for passengers to complain about the chaos that has dominated airports since the start of the holiday season. These problems could easily have been predicted.

No one can seriously believe that a business model whereby passengers are transported from A to B for such a ridiculously low price is sustainable. When flights cost a fraction of a train ticket, something must be wrong. Costs are either being disregarded or passed on to someone else.


Or this cost is being financed by hidden government subsidies that apply to various elements of air travel – whether it’s taxpayers’ money being used to build planes and airports or tax cuts on kerosene. Or it’s the customers who pay, through poor service that costs them time and causes stress, as is so often the case these days. Even with air travel, the basic rule of the market economy applies: there’s no such thing as a free lunch. Someone always pays – and in the worst case scenario, those who pay the price are third parties such as the climate, the environment or future generations.

Too cheap for the service delivered

Even one of the founding fathers of cheap air travel – Michael O’Leary, who has been CEO of Ryanair for almost 30 years – has admitted that flights are too cheap. The Financial Times quoted him as saying that it was ridiculous that in London the journey to the airport costs more than the flight itself. He said flying was simply “too cheap for what it is”. Consequently, O’Leary also announced that in the next few years, Ryanair would raise average ticket prices from the current rate of 40 euros to 50 or 60 euros.

They are reaching for tired old policies that should have been consigned to the history books

But the reaction from German politicians is the opposite. They do not want to admit that air travel needs to be more expensive and are persisting under the illusion that cheap flights can be sustainable, although their predecessors have long given up on that dream.

They could encourage companies to hire more qualified staff and pay those who work on planes and at airports – in security or baggage handling – a higher salary to create more attractive jobs, which are being lost in other industries through digitalization, automation and machines. Instead, they are reaching for tired old policies that should have been consigned to the history books long ago – genuinely suggesting bringing in Turkish immigrants as cheap labor to allow the cost of air travel to remain as low as it has always been.

windowseat

Airplane window seat

Alexander Schimmeck / Unsplash

Lessons from the past

They have clearly learned nothing from the mistakes of the past. In the 1960s, the government tried a similar tactic, using migrant workers to plug holes in the job market. Millions of workers were employed in factory assembly lines across Germany, doing back-breaking work for a salary that no German was prepared to settle for. And then people were surprised that those who came did not go back to their home country afterwards.

Turkish migrant workers were seen as a cheap solution, but the policy created expensive problems. Immigration cannot be so precisely controlled that it exclusively suits the needs of the host country. It follows its own path, with unforeseen long-term consequences such as migrants bringing their families to join them.

Unlike machines, people cannot be easily, quickly and cheaply moved around the economy like pawns on a chessboard.

Skilled workers don't come cheap

Calls for cheap migrant labor, or for more or better-targeted immigration, misunderstand basic market forces. Politicians are not prepared to tackle a labor shortage by improving working conditions or raising salaries. They want flights to stay cheap at all costs. But they are deliberately ignoring the costs in terms of integration that a rise in immigration entails. Fundamentally, they are refusing to acknowledge that skilled workers don’t come cheap.

The vicious cycle of cheap labor will become a real and very pressing problem

It is the same as trying to tackle a shortage of care workers through imposing a year of compulsory service. It is the same attitude that claims being a soldier is so easy that anyone can do it. Or that care work doesn’t require any special skills or qualities. Similarly, the shortage of airport staff cannot be resolved through migrant labor. Undervaluing skilled workers in this way will simply put off anyone who wants to earn a decent salary.

That means the shortage will get even worse and the complaints will grow louder. The vicious cycle of cheap labor will become a real and very pressing problem. It would be far more sensible to allow flights to become more expensive and pay airline workers better. That is the only way to improve efficiency, productivity, satisfaction and living standards in the long term.

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Already a subscriber? Log in
Society

Single Parents In Portugal Turn "It Takes A Village" Into A Practical Reality

The death of a young child left alone at home while his single mother was out shocked a community. Now, single parents have banded together to offer support to each other. And they're succeeding in the face of overwhelming challenges.

Single Parents In Portugal Turn "It Takes A Village" Into A Practical Reality

Women from the association Jangada D'Emoções, which started Colo100Horas

Maíra Streit

SINTRA — The large and curious eyes of Gurnaaz Kaur reveal her desire to understand the world.

This four-year-old Indian girl doesn’t speak Portuguese yet. A few months have passed since she left her country on the family adventure across the European continent. She uses a few gestures to try to express herself and greets people with a “bom dia” (good morning), one of the few expressions he has learned.

Nahary Conniott, 8, is also looking for ways to interact. From Angola and on the autism spectrum disorder, she has already experienced difficult situations and was asked to leave the private school she attended. In the other schools in which the mother enrolled her, the refusal was always justified by the lack of vacancies.

Children with such different paths found the support they deserved in the Colo100Horas project. Started in 2021, it is a self-organized network of women who came together to help immigrants with their immense daily challenges in Sintra, in western Portugal.

The long list of problems meant they banded together to look for a solution: the strenuous routine of caring for children (still imposed in most homes as the responsibility of women), low salaries, the overcrowding of daycare centers, excessive work and the difficulty with shift schedules, which is common in jobs in the catering and cleaning industries.

A tragic case that occurred recently in the neighborhood that drew attention to the need for greater support for families: a six-year-old boy died after falling from the ninth floor of the building where he lived. He was at home with only his two little brothers, while his mother had left to go to the market, a few meters away.

Keep reading...Show less

You've reached your limit of free articles.

To read the full story, start your free trial today.

Get unlimited access. Cancel anytime.

Exclusive coverage from the world's top sources, in English for the first time.

Insights from the widest range of perspectives, languages and countries.

Already a subscriber? Log in

The latest

InterNations